Determination of the depth of the corrosion pit is essential to predict the serviceability of corrosion affected pipes and to instigate maintenance and repairs for the pipeline system. In this paper, a reliability-based methodology for serviceability assessment of corrosion affected pipes is presented. The depth of corrosion pit is considered as the critical parameter that causes serviceability failure when it is greater than the wall thickness of the pipe. A stochastic model for corrosion depth of cast iron pipes is developed and a time-dependent method is employed to quantify the probability of serviceability failure so that the time for the pipeline to be unserviceable and hence requiring repairs can be determined. A sensitivity analysis is also undertaken to identify the factors that affect the failure due to corrosion. The methodology presented in this study can be used as a tool for infrastructure managers in different industries such as water distribution systems, oil and gas pipelines, sewer networks, etc. The methodology can help pipeline engineers and asset managers in making decisions with regard to the serviceability of corrosion affected pipelines both for assessment of existing systems and for designing new pipelines.
Corrosion in pipes is the predominant causal factor in the premature degradation of ferrous pipes, leading to ultimate structural failure. For pipes, failure does not necessarily imply structural collapse but in most cases involves the loss of serviceability, characterized by leakage. Pipes might not reach their ultimate structural failure but from a serviceability point of view they might fail when there is leakage from corrosion pits. Since the safety factors used in design for structural strength are usually larger than those for serviceability (due to the paramount importance of structural safety) the actual probability of loss of strength is smaller than that of loss of serviceability. As is well known, the costs of repairs are usually high for pipelines (in addition to the inconvenience to the public due to interruptions), it is of practical importance to accurately predict the time for repairs for deteriorated pipes to achieve a risk-cost optimized asset management of the pipeline system. This gives rise to the need for a reliability analysis on corrosion affected pipes with various failure criteria.
Determination of the depth of the corrosion pit can help to predict the serviceability of corrosion affected pipes and to instigate maintenance and repairs for the pipeline system. The reliability of pipelines subjected to corrosion has been investigated extensively in the past (e.g. Rajani et al. 2000; Caleyo et al. 2002; De Silva et al. 2006; Stephens & Nessim 2006; Maes et al. 2008; Li & Mahmoodian 2013; Routil et al. 2015). In these investigations, the pipeline system parameters have been assumed to be either deterministic quantities or random variables. Compared with deterministic approaches, stochastic methods are more realistic because in reality variables of the system are not only uncertain but also change with time. As such, it is more appropriate for them to be modeled as stochastic processes.
Assessment of pipe infrastructure requires the collection of a wide range of data for developing models for pipe deterioration, based on which the service life of pipe systems can be predicted.
In deterministic models, normally data from laboratory tests are used to produce the necessary data and establish the relationships between components. Variations and uncertainties in variables are not considered in deterministic models. Rajani et al. (2000) proposed a deterministic model to estimate the remaining service life of cast iron water pipes. It considers that the corrosion pits reduce the structural capacity of the pipes, but it does not consider the uncertainties involved in all factors contributing to the corrosion and resultant failures. Deb et al. (2002) presented a deterministic model based on analyzing the growth of corrosion pits on cast iron (CI) pipes, loss of wall thickness and the strength reduction of the pipe over time.
Probabilistic models are used when historical failure or inspection data are limited or unavailable. These models specifically analyze the effective parameters on pipe performance rather than evaluate the previous pipe failure history. Uncertainties are included by considering the variables as random variables. Usually, this method is applied to pipes where the process of deterioration and factors for failure are well understood.
Sadiq et al. (2004) developed a probabilistic method to predict the remaining service life of in service cast iron pipes based on Monte Carlo simulation. They defined maximum principal strain as the failure criterion and considered stresses both in the longitudinal and circumferential directions. De Silva et al. (2006) presented a condition assessment and probabilistic analysis to estimate failure rates in ferrous pipelines. A first-order-second moment (FOSM) analysis was combined with condition assessment data to determine the probability of failure. Davis & Marlow (2008) developed a probabilistic failure model for service life prediction of CI pipelines subject to corrosion and under internal pressure and external loading.
Mahmoodian & Li (2011) used the Monte Carlo simulation method in reliability analysis for time-dependent service life prediction of buried cast iron water pipes. The failure criterion in their study was defined as the exceedance of stress intensity factor from fracture toughness of pipe material.
Li & Mahmoodian (2013) also presented an analytical methodology for failure analysis and service life prediction of cast iron pipes using a time-dependent reliability theory. They considered ultimate failure of the pipe by using the concept of stress intensity in fracture mechanics. An empirical model was derived in their study for maximum pit growth of corrosion from the available data based on mathematical regressions.
Although structural integrity of pipelines has been the main concern in failure assessment of the infrastructure in all of the above mentioned research, serviceability assessment can be of more practical importance as the warning stage before ultimate collapse.
In serviceability assessment, it is the corrosion depth that is of the most practical significance and of real concern to pipeline engineers, operators and asset managers. Moreover, repair costs arising from corrosion induced serviceability failures, in particular pipe leakage, exceed those arising from strength failures by a substantial margin. It is therefore essential to predict accurately the serviceability of corrosion affected pipes based on the criterion of corrosion depth so as to achieve cost effectiveness in the asset management of pipeline infrastructure. Timely repairs have the potential to prolong the service life of a pipeline system.
In this paper a reliability-based methodology for serviceability assessment of corrosion affected cast iron pipes is presented. A stochastic model for corrosion depth is developed which relates to key factors that affect the depth of corrosion pit.
Serviceability of a pipeline system fails when it starts to leak, i.e. the depth of corrosion pit is equal to the pipe wall thickness. An analytical time-dependent method is employed to quantify the probability of serviceability failure of cast iron pipes due to corrosion so that the time for the pipeline to be unserviceable and hence requiring repairs, can be determined with confidence.
A sensitivity analysis is also undertaken to identify the factors that affect the failure due to corrosion. The methodology presented in this study can serve as a tool for infrastructure managers in different industries such as water distribution systems, oil and gas pipelines, sewer networks, etc.
Accurate prediction of pipe failure probability will help asset managers to better plan for water pipe networks; preventing environmental pollution, flooding and disruption of the daily life of the public. The methodology can help pipeline managers and maintenance engineers to accurately estimate the probability of pipeline failures which can be used for prioritizing pipe repairs and/or replacement based on their risk analysis. Decision making methods and risk-cost analysis are out of the scope of the current research and will not be covered in this paper.
For Equation (8) to be of practical use, i.e., determining the probability of serviceability failure due to corrosion over time, the key is to develop a stochastic model for the corrosion depth. This is dealt with in the next section.
MODEL OF CORROSION DEPTH
The predominant deterioration mechanism on the ferrous pipes is corrosion with the damage occuring in the form of corrosion pits. The damage to iron is often identified by the presence of graphitization, a result of iron being leached away by corrosion. The characteristics of the soil in contact with the pipe surface, such as pH, soluble salt, oxygen and moisture content, soil resistivity, temperature and presence of certain bacteria affect the corrosion rate (Cast Iron Soil Pipe and Fittings Handbook 2006).
As a common form of metal loss, the corrosion pit can grow with time and result in reduction of the thickness and mechanical resistance of the pipe wall. Corrosion pits have a variety of shapes with characteristic depths, diameters (or widths), and lengths. They can develop randomly along any segment of pipe and tend to grow with time at a rate that depends on environmental conditions in the immediate vicinity of the pipeline (Rajani & Makar 2000).
The metal corrosion phenomenon is complex, and the depth of corrosion pit due to both internal and external corrosions, as well as whether the rate is constant or variable, have been the subject of debate (Snoeyink & Wagner 1996; Melchers 2008). However, in all cases, the corrosion rate is generally considered to be high during early pipe ages and then stabilizes at a certain value thereafter. In the first phase a rapid growth of the corrosion pits occurs because any corrosion products formed on the pipe surface are porous and have poor protective properties. In the second phase a slow growth of the corrosion pits leading to a constant corrosion depth occurs due to auto-protection of corrosion layers. This complexity of the corrosion phenomena leads to the different corrosion models and different suggested definitions of corrosion based on the different assumptions made by researchers (Yamini & Lence 2010).
In this paper, a power law corrosion model is assumed since over a long period (i.e. in old pipes) the localized corrosion pits grow to the point where they are in contact with one another, making individual pits indistinguishable and causing the pipe to appear to have a uniform corrosion (Benjamin et al. 1996).
In practice the constants k and n are obtained by fitting the model to the experimental data, therefore having a good regression (i.e. high R-squared value) would be a proof for choosing an appropriate model.
With high R-squared values for regression lines in Figure 1 (internal , external ), it can be concluded that the power law model best fits the corrosion data and it is appropriate for corrosion modelling and the calculations.
|Symbol .||Parameter .||Corrosion type .||Mean .||Coefficient of variation .|
|Symbol .||Parameter .||Corrosion type .||Mean .||Coefficient of variation .|
PROBABILITY OF FAILURE
Finally, as a complete picture of serviceability assessment of corrosion affected pipes, the time for the structure to be unserviceable, i.e. , due to corrosion, can be determined for a given acceptable probability . This is straightforward. For example, from Figure 4(a), it can be obtained that Tc = 53 years for (and auto-correlation of ). If there is no intervention during the service period of (0, 53) years for the pipe, such as maintenance and repairs, represents the time for interventions or the end of service for the pipe, based on the performance criterion of corrosion depth. The information of (i.e. time for interventions) is of significant practical importance to pipeline engineers and asset managers of pipeline systems in decision-making with regard to its repairs and/or rehabilitation which are usually dependent on the budget situation of the day. Therefore, when to intervene is the first question for decision-makers.
In view of variables that affect the corrosion process, it is of interest to identify the degree of contribution of variables so that more research can focus on the most effective variable. The contribution of these variables in the failure function is calculated by using the relative contribution concept.
It is also observed that the variability of the parameters (k and n) for low values of t, has more significant effect on the probability of failure. In other words, the sensitivity of corrosion parameters is more dependent on the actual value of coefficient of variation in the early ages. In such cases, more concern should be taken in order to determine relevant parameter values.
A reliability based methodology for serviceability assessment of cast iron water pipes has been formulated and applied to the limit state function which defines serviceability failure as the condition when corrosion depth becomes greater than pipe wall thickness. The stochastic nature of the problem was considered by introducing uncertain variables as random variables.
The concept of corrosion depth increment has been employed to establish the limit state function for determining the probability of serviceability failure. A widely used model for a corrosion pit has been adopted based on data mining and mathematical regressions. From the results of a sensitivity analysis it has been found that the likelihood of pipe collapse increases with the decrease of the wall thickness of the pipes for both external and internal corrosion and that for a given diameter, the likelihood of pipe collapse for pipes with external corrosion is much higher than that for pipes with internal corrosion.
Sensitivity analysis showed that among corrosion constants, the multiplying constant (k) has a higher contribution in failure function at the early ages and as time passes, the contribution of exponential constant (n) become higher. The result also showed that the sensitivity of corrosion parameters is more dependent on the actual value of coefficient of variation in early ages.
It can be concluded that a time-dependent reliability method is a rational tool for serviceability assessment of corrosion affected pipes with a view to determine the time of repairs and/or rehabilitation for the pipeline.
The method also can be used for optimizing the design of new water mains by knowing the sensitivity of the system to the pipeline variables.