Escherichia coli and other enteric pathogens presence indicate that the water has been contaminated with fecal matter. River deltas are population hotspots which are becoming increasingly urbanized and where poor sanitation has been frequently identified as a pressing issue. In this study, we have investigated the spatial distribution of E. coli in river deltas under varying river discharge, temperature and irradiation at the water surface. A hydrodynamic and water quality model has been used to reproduce an idealized river delta configuration and to investigate the spatial distribution of E. coli across the delta floodplain and channels. The concentration of E. coli rapidly declines downstream, following a tripartite trend with different decline rates on the delta front, pro-delta and shelf area. The highest differences in the spatial distribution of E. coli bacteria occur for low-river discharge values. Temperature and irradiation both influence the concentration of E. coli and mostly influence downstream areas and smaller channels.
Around 50% of the world population live in the proximity of the sea, and river deltas are among the most populated areas in the world (Leonardi et al. 2013; Fagherazzi et al. 2015; Edmonds et al. 2017). Large amounts of wastewater are discharged daily into coastal areas, including wastes from coastal communities without adequate sewage or wastewater depuration systems (Shuval 2003). Several health issues are associated with the bathing/swimming in wastewater polluted water and with the consumption of seafood harvested in wastewater polluted coastal areas. Epidemiological studies analyzed by the WHO support the view that certain enteric and respiratory infections and diseases are associated with bathing in coastal waters contaminated with pathogenic microorganisms (Fattal et al. 1987). Seafood, especially bivalves which are frequently undercooked, can transmit serious infectious diseases. Infectious hepatitis A (HAV), a serious disease of the liver, is frequently transmitted by shellfish (e.g. Shuval 2003). Pathogenic bacteria can survive in the coastal environments for weeks, and viruses can survive for months. According to Gerba (1988), HAV can survive in the sea for over a year. Enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli has been identified as the most common cause of infectious diarrhea for young children in developing countries (Rao et al. 2003). As an example, in a cohort of 397 children from two villages located in the Nile Delta, 3,477 episodes of diarrhea were registered with an average of 5.5 episodes of diarrhea per child per year (Rao et al. 2003). In a study conducted on the Niger Delta, the bacteria count showed a clear exceedance of the international standard of drinking water with the presence of E. coli and other enteric pathogens such as Enterobacteria, indicating that the water was significantly polluted with fecal matter (Williams et al. 2018). In the Pearl River Delta and near the urban area of Shenzen, due to the high levels of organic pollution, the overall water quality was only marginally acceptable to the 2nd Class Standard of the State Surface Environmental Quality Standards (Ho et al. 2001). Globally, it has been estimated that diaharrea accounts for 25% of child deaths under 5 years old and is the second most common cause of child deaths from infectious diseases followed by pneumonia (Pneumonia & Diarrhea Progress Report 2017; Saha et al. 2019). India, Nigeria, Pakistan, Republic of Congo and Angola are among the most affected by early diarrheal deaths (Saha et al. 2019). A recent global analysis has suggested that the population on deltas is growing from 237 million in 2000 to projected 322 million in 2020, with population density also growing from an average of 322 people per km2 in 2000 to projected 422 people per km2 in 2020 (Edmonds et al. 2017). For deltaic regions, there is increasing concern about pollution because the coastline receives huge amounts of human and industrial waste, including organic pollutants from municipal and domestic sewage (Sojinu et al. 2012). For some low lying deltaic regions, which are currently under development, gastrointestinal disease outcomes are also more severe due to the malnutrition and lack of intervention strategies for the region (e.g. Ashbolt 2004).
The survival and dispersal of fecal bacteria depend on physiochemical conditions and on the physical dilution due to hydrodynamics. Among the various physiochemical conditions, temperature and irradiation play a crucially important role and these variables are expected to vary under future climate change scenarios (e.g. Mancini 1978; IPCC 2013). In spite of numerous insightful studies, more efforts are needed to understand the distribution and transport of potentially infectious microorganisms along the coastline and possible risks to human health.
In this work, we will focus on the transport patterns of E. coli along an idealized river delta network and for different temperature, solar radiation and river discharge values.
This article aims to unravel the impact of temperature and irradiation on the mortality rate and concentration of E. coli along channel networks and along different portions of the river delta. To achieve this, we focus on the mortality rate and concentration decay of E. coli with the distance from the river mouth with different discharge conditions on changes in E. coli concentration with the bifurcation order and changes in E. coli concentration with different radiation and temperatures.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The numerical model was used for the creation of the idealized river delta bathymetry used in this study. The idealized delta model presents a typical river-dominated configuration with several braches and bifurcation order up to 3 (Figure 1(a)). Channels width and depth decrease with the channel order as typically found in river-dominated river deltas (Figure 1(a)). The morphology of the system was kept constant throughout the simulations. The velocity field of the system for a river discharge of 100 m3/s is also presented in Figure 1(b) where red colors indicate the highest velocity values and blue colors indicate no-velocity.
Figure 1(c) shows the spatial distribution of E. coli across the domain and for the 100 m3/s discharge rate. For a discharge of 100 m3/s, the concentration of E. coli rapidly declines and there are large variations in E. coli concentration across the domain. As the river discharge increases (Figure 2), the plume spreads further away from the river mouth with lower concentration values covering a wider portion of the river delta. Furthermore, as the river discharge increases, the decline in E. coli follows an increasingly more pronounced tripartite trend with an initially gentler decline on the delta plain and main channels, a steeper decline on the pro-delta regions and another low rate decline on the seaward side of the domain (Figure 2).
Figure 3(a) illustrates changes in E. coli concentration with the stream order (being zero the main river channel), and for temperatures ranging from 15°C to 28°C. Highest concentrations are present when the temperature is the lowest; this is in agreement with Equation (1) which predicts an increase in the mortality rate with temperature. The E. coli concentration significantly declines as the stream order increases. Notably, the highest differences in E. coli concentration due to different temperatures are present for the lowest concentration and the highest bifurcation order (Figure 3(a)).
Figure 3(b) illustrates changes in E. coli concentration for different irradiation of the water surface, ranging from 100 to 350 W/m2. Maximum concentrations are present for the lowest values of radiation. Radiation has a stronger effect for highest stream order values where the water depth is lower in agreement with Equation (1). For channels of stream order 3, the average values of E. coli concentration are only present for radiation values lower than 300 W/m2. Similarly, than for the impact of temperature, the influence of irradiation is significantly more noticeable for higher bifurcation orders.
DISCUSSIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
In this study, we have used an idealized river delta configuration to investigate the spatial distribution of E. coli bacteria over a river delta. We further investigated the influence of temperature and surface water radiation on the concentration of E. coli.
We found that:
The concentration of E. coli bacteria inside the deltaic channels rapidly declines with the bifurcation order.
Temperature and irradiation both influence the concentration of E. coli and mostly influence downstream areas and smaller channels.
The highest differences in the spatial distribution of E. coli bacteria occur for low-river discharge values.
Adopting the bifurcation order as a synthetic descriptor of deltas' geometry supports the upscaling of our results to deltaic regions of different sizes and with different morphologies, as the bifurcation order is frequently used as a non-dimensional metric to describe channels networking independently from local morphological features. As the bifurcation order increases, channel depth and width decrease, and the influence of temperature and water surface irradiation also increases. Some limitations are associated with the use of our idealized modeling framework. For instance, the model does not include simulations for an entire catchment area which would be necessary to investigate the influence of different land uses as well as the dynamic interactions between land and ocean. Wang et al. (2019) provide an example of a catchment scale approach for the monitoring of water quality in Singapore's coastal areas. Specifically, they combined 1D-hydrological/hydraulic, transport models as well as 3D-hydrodynamic and water quality models. By incorporating catchment characteristics, the model of Wang et al. (2019) allowed incorporating point sources such as sewage treatments, industries as well as diffuse sources from agriculture. The latter are an important inclusion for the accurate monitoring of the spatial and temporal distribution of water quality parameters along the coastline. Field investigations should be also conducted in support of numerical modeling. For instance, in order to investigate water quality in the Singapore coastal water, Goh et al. (2017) measured in situ chemical contaminants and bacteria. Specifically, they used Colilert™ and Enterolert™ (IDEXX Laboratories, Inc., Westbrook, Maine) to quantify E. coli and Enterococcus concentrations. Goh et al. (2017) further combined field investigation with principal component analysis (PCA) and provided insight into the spatial variations in Singapore's water quality in support of health risk assessments. To accurately model water quality, Wang et al. (2016) further proposed a new framework combining modeling and data assimilation techniques. Their framework allowed information extracted from observations to feed into a data-driven local/modified local model and results from the data-driven model to be then fed into the original process-based model for the improvement of forecast abilities. The application of our modeling framework to a real case scenario and validation with real data is outside from the scope of this article but might be the object of future studies.
The influence of both temperature and irradiation on the average E. coli concentration is almost undetectable within the main river (stream order zero), but significantly increases further from the river mouth where different temperatures and irradiation values can determine the presence or absence of E. coli bacteria.
Our results suggest that daily or seasonal variations in temperature and radiation, as well as possible changes in climate extremes or mean values might potentially have a stronger impact, in terms of E. coli concentration, on those channels with a higher bifurcation order where temperature or irradiation-induced fluctuations are the highest.