The results showed that the precipitation in the study area was mainly in a downward trend before the mid-1930s, and then turned upward. In the 1950s, the precipitation generally showed a distribution of rising in the west and falling in the east, and this trend continued until the early 21st century. By 2007, except for the central part of the Continental Basin, the overall trend was mainly upward. In this study, 65 El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) events were identified, including 24 El Niño events and 41 La Niña events. The precipitation was generally less when ENSO occurred. However, there were differences in the type and intensity of the event. For example, El Niño had a greater impact on precipitation than La Niña did, and extremely strong or strong El Niño/La Niña events had a more significant impact than moderate, weak, or extremely weak ones. The correlation between precipitation and El Niño or La Niña events had some similarities and differences. For example, precipitation was mainly negatively correlated with El Niño and La Niña at the same time, and both correlations were proportional to intensity, but the correlation between precipitation and El Niño was significantly stronger than that of La Niña.

  • Most of the studies classified the types of ENSO based on the location, and this paper classified it by intensity.

  • Most of the studies were carried out on the seasonal scale, the annual scale is still relatively lacking.

  • Most studies focused on the qualitative relationship between precipitation and ENSO, this paper quantified the relationship.

  • The study area in this paper was wider, and the results were more representative.

The El Niño/La Niña Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is not only the strongest inter-annual oscillation in the earth's climate system but also an important factor that indirectly affects precipitation through the teleconnection between ocean and atmosphere, which has a significant impact on the climate in most parts of the world, including China (Chen & Lian 2020). Therefore, discussing the relationship between annual precipitation and ENSO in China is one of the most important research tasks at present (Wang et al. 2022).

Based on observational or dynamic simulation data, many scholars have used wavelet coherence (which is a time-normalized and scale-resolved method to specify the correlation between two time series) (Araghi et al. 2017), singular value decomposition (Liu et al. 2019b), Empirical Orthogonal Function decomposition (Sapna et al. 2019), Mann–Whitney U hypothesis test (Lee & Julien 2016), Community Earth System Model (Liguori et al. 2022), and other methods to explore the relationship between precipitation and ENSO in the globe (Ropelewski & Halpert 1987; Dai & Wigley 2000), as well as South America (Souza et al. 2021), Asia (Chen et al. 2018; Wen et al. 2019), the tropical Pacific (Christine & Scott 2016), Canada (Nalley et al. 2019), China (Wang et al. 2022), northern Mexico (Omar et al. 2020), and other places under the scale of month, season and year. The results showed that ENSO was the link between SSTA and atmospheric anomalies in the tropical Pacific Ocean, which can not only affect the climate conditions in the tropical Pacific Ocean but also cause precipitation anomalies, even large-scale extreme precipitation events (Chai 2022) globally through teleconnection (Shimizu et al. 2017). Global land mean annual precipitation decreased by about 12 mm in El Niño years, and increased by about 11.7 mm in La Niña years on average (Li & Zhao 2019). ENSO was also one of the main factors modulating precipitation in South America (Souza et al. 2021), Africa (Emmanuel 2022), China (Liu et al. 2019a, 2019b), and other places. Precipitation in spring, autumn, and winter in Central Asia was highly correlated with ENSO (Chen et al. 2018). When ENSO was in the positive/negative phase, there was obviously less/more precipitation in Canada (Nalley et al. 2019), while there was more/less precipitation in the Andes (Jonaitis et al. 2021) and southern California (Du et al. 2020). When ENSO was in the positive phase, the summer precipitation anomaly in eastern China showed a ‘tripolar’ spatial distribution of drought in the north and south and flood in the central part. When ENSO was in the negative phase, the summer precipitation formed a ‘northwestward-southwestward’ rain-band with less rain along the ‘Hu-Huanyong Line’ (Wang et al. 2022). There was a strong correlation between the El Niño phase and precipitation in northern Mexico (Omar et al. 2020). Some scholars also proposed that there were temporal differences in teleconnection between precipitation and ENSO (Torbenson et al. 2019). For example, the correlation between precipitation and ENSO in the southeast of the United States from April to September was significantly lower than that from October to next March (Nam & Baigorria 2015). There was a strong response relationship between precipitation and ENSO in summer and autumn in Indonesia, but in spring and winter, such a relationship was quite the opposite (Rahman et al. 2014). The correlation between ENSO and precipitation in China had strong regional and seasonal differences, as did its impact on precipitation (Gong & Wang 1999). For example, there was a significant positive correlation between summer precipitation and ENSO in northeastern China after 1997 (Han et al. 2017). The correlation of winter precipitation with ENSO and mid-latitude north Atlantic sea surface temperature in northwest China was weak in the mid-1990s, and then became significantly stronger. When ENSO was in the positive phase and the mid-latitude north Atlantic sea surface temperature was in the negative phase, the precipitation increased significantly (Yin & Zhou 2020). There was a decrease in precipitation in the arid region in El Niño years but an increase in precipitation in the spring and summer of the following year (Li & Zhao 2019).

Existing relevant results demonstrated that precipitation had different sensitivities in response to different types of ENSO events (Jia & Zhang 2020). Yet the types of ENSO events were usually divided by the location of occurrence, and rarely used accumulated SSTA as an indicator, divided ENSO event with intensity to quantify the sensitivity of precipitation to ENSO events with different types and intensities. Most of the research was carried out on a seasonal scale (Zhang et al. 2022a), with fewer inter-annual scales.

Based on what has been mentioned above, to make the research results highly representative and comprehensive, this article chose China as the study area, for it covered a vast expanse of land with a large number of climate types. Based on precipitation and SSTA raster data from January 1901 to December 2020, the response of precipitation and ENSO with different intensities was comprehensively revealed, which can enrich the research results in this field and provide a reference for disaster prevention.

Study area

The study area is China (the map used was downloaded from the resource and environmental science data center), with a total area of about 9.6 × 106 km2. The terrain of China from west to east is very different, with complex and multiple landforms (e.g., deserts, mountains, plains, and basins) as well as a variety of temperature zones and climate types (e.g., temperate zone, tropical zone, and plateau climate), see Figure 1 for detail. China consists of nine major watersheds (Deng et al. 2020): Songhua and Liaohe River Basin, Haihe River Basin, Huaihe River Basin, Yellow River Basin, Yangtze River Basin, Pearl River Basin, Southeast Basin, Southwest Basin, and Continental Basin (Figure 1(b)).
Figure 1

Location of the study area.

Figure 1

Location of the study area.

Close modal

Data used

The precipitation data used was the raster data set of monthly precipitation at 1 km resolution in China, which came from ‘national earth system science data center’ (http://www.geodata.cn/) and was provided by Professor Shouzhang Peng's team of Northwest A&F University (Peng 2019). The Oceanic Niño Index (ONI) data used was from the ERSST.v5 data set provided by the National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) (https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/teleconnections/enso/). After format conversion, extraction by mask, and calculation, the mean value of the SSTA in the Niño 3.4 region (Figure 2(a)) from January 1901 to December 2020 was obtained (Figure 2(b)), and then the ONI was calculated. The duration of the two data sets was 120 years, and the formats of the two were tiff.
Figure 2

Location of the Niño 3.4 region and monthly SSTA data.

Figure 2

Location of the Niño 3.4 region and monthly SSTA data.

Close modal

Method

  • (1)

    The model builder in Arcgis software was used for coordinate transformation and extraction to obtain monthly data of SSTA in the Niño 3.4 region and precipitation in China.

  • (2)

    The band collection statistics tool in Arcgis software was used to calculate the regional mean value of precipitation in the study area.

  • (3)
    The linear regression model was used to simulate the variation of precipitation. The formula is (Ma et al. 2016):
    (1)
    where is the annual change rate; is the precipitation in year i; here, n was 120.
  • (4)
    The moving average method was used to conduct an auxiliary analysis of the variation in precipitation. The formula is (Shang et al. 2018):
    (2)
  • Here, n was 11.

  • (5)
    The coefficient of variation (CV) is a value to measure the fluctuation degree of a variable (here it was precipitation, which is indicated by x in the following formula), a higher CV value indicates a higher degree of fluctuation in the variable (Pan 2022). The formula is:
    (3)

In addition, according to the fluctuation degree of precipitation, it was divided into five levels, which were: CV > 0.4 (high fluctuation), 0.3 < CV ≤0.4 (relatively high fluctuation), 0.2 < CV ≤ 0.3 (moderate fluctuation), 0.1 < CV ≤ 0.2 (relatively low fluctuation), and CV < 0.1 (low fluctuation).

  • (6)
    The Mann–Kendall trend test was used to identify the significance of precipitation change (Saleem et al. 2021). The formulas are as follows:
    (4)
    (5)
    (6)
    (7)
    where is the value of precipitation in year j (k); S is the Kendall statistic; is the variance of S; Z is the test statistics.
  • (7)
    The Pearson correlation coefficient between precipitation and ENSO was calculated using following formula:
    (8)
    where is the precipitation in year i; is the ONI in year i.

Criteria for classification of ENSO

According to the definition of ONI and ENSO given by NOAA: ENSO is a phenomenon in the equatorial Pacific Ocean characterized by a five consecutive 3 month running mean of SSTA in the Niño 3.4 region that is above (below) the threshold of +0.5 °C (−0.5 °C). This standard of measure is known as the ONI. On the basis of this standard, a total of 24 El Niño events and 41 La Niña events were identified this time.

In order to explore the response relationship between precipitation and ENSO more comprehensively, based on previous research results (Li & Zhai 2000), this article divided ENSO events into two categories and 10 subcategories with intensity: extremely strong El Niño/La Niña, strong El Niño/La Niña, moderate El Niño/La Niña, weak El Niño/La Niña and extremely weak El Niño/La Niña. See Table 1 for details.

Table 1

Criteria for ENSO event classification

IntensityExtremely strongStrongModerateWeakExtremely weak
El Niño ≤17.0 14.1–17.0 7.1–14.0 4.6–7.0 ≤4.5 
La Niña ≤− 15.0 −12.1 to −15 −6.1 to −12.0 −3.6 to −6.0 ≤− 3.5 
IntensityExtremely strongStrongModerateWeakExtremely weak
El Niño ≤17.0 14.1–17.0 7.1–14.0 4.6–7.0 ≤4.5 
La Niña ≤− 15.0 −12.1 to −15 −6.1 to −12.0 −3.6 to −6.0 ≤− 3.5 

Temporal and spatial variation characteristics of precipitation

Figure 3 shows the temporal evolution of the regional mean value of precipitation (a), the spatial distribution of the multi-year mean value of precipitation (b), the spatial distribution of the annual change rate of precipitation (c–f) and CV (g–j) in 1901–1925 (T1), 1926–1950 (T2), 1951–2006 (T3), and 2007–2020 (T4).
Figure 3

Temporal and spatial variation characteristics of precipitation.

Figure 3

Temporal and spatial variation characteristics of precipitation.

Close modal

The average annual precipitation in the study area was 547.3 mm, the maximum value of precipitation appeared in 2016 (642.4 mm), and the minimum value appeared in 2011 (508.6 mm). The precipitation decreased from 1901 to 1925 and then increased from 1926 to 1950. After entering the 1950s, the precipitation generally showed a downward trend again, and this trend continued until the early 21st century. By 2007, the overall trend in precipitation was upward. In terms of space, the maximum value of the multi-year average was distributed in the southeast of the study area, and the total annual precipitation exceeded 1,400 mm as a whole. The minimum values were concentrated in Xinjiang, western Tibet, and western Inner Mongolia, where the annual precipitation was mostly less than 200 mm, the overall distribution increased from northwest to southeast.

It can be seen from Figure 3(c) that during the T1 period, the overall precipitation in the study area showed a downward trend, and this part of the area accounted for 68.3% of the total. Among them, the area where precipitation decreased significantly accounted for about one-third of the total area (the area passed the significance test at a confidence level of 95%), mainly distributed in the Continental Basin, the Yellow River Basin, and the junction of the Huaihe River Basin and the Yangtze River Basin. Except for the Haihe River Basin and Huaihe River Basin, where the precipitation fluctuated greatly, the precipitation in other areas was relatively stable, and most of them belonged to the low fluctuation area or the relatively low fluctuation area. The area where the precipitation increased significantly was mainly concentrated at the junction of the Yangtze River Basin and the Pearl River Basin, accounting for 13.5% of the total study area. The rising rate was greater than 6 mm/a, and the variation over the years was relatively stable. The precipitation in other areas did not change significantly, which failed the significance test, and the variation rate was mostly between −3.6 and 2.4 mm/a. The overall precipitation in the study area during the T2 period was mainly on the upward trend, this part of the area accounted for 55.4% of the total, and the areas passing the significance test accounted for 38.7% of the total, mainly distributed in the Continental Basin, the Yellow River Basin, and the Southeast Basin. Among them, the Continental Basin had the fastest rising rate, followed by the Yellow River Basin and the Southeast Basin. Except for the Southeast Basin, which belonged to the moderate fluctuation area, the precipitation in other areas was relatively stable, and most of those areas belonged to the low fluctuation area. In addition, 44.6% of the study area showed a decreasing trend, mainly distributed in the northern part of the Continental Basin, the southern part of the Southwest Basin, and the Songhua and Liaohe River Basin. The variation rate was concentrated between 1.5 and 2.5 mm/a, which failed to pass the significance test, and the decreasing trend was not significant. In the T3 period, except for a weak downward trend in the west of the Southwest Basins and a weak upward trend at the junction of the Huaihe River Basin and the Yangtze River Basin, the overall precipitation in the study area increased in the west and decreased in the east. The two covered a nearly equivalent part of the study area and accounted for 52.1 and 47.9% of the total study area, respectively. The precipitation in the former area increased significantly in the Continental Basin and passed the significance test at a confidence level of 95%, yet the degree of fluctuation was relatively large (most of them were in the moderate fluctuation area or above). The precipitation in the latter area decreased significantly in the eastern Songhua and Liaohe River Basin, the eastern Yellow River Basin, the central Yangtze River Basin, and the Haihe River Basin. Among them, except for the central Yangtze River Basin, with less fluctuation, the rest of the areas all belonged to the moderate fluctuation areas. After entering the T4 period, except for the downward trend in the central Continental Basin and the Southwest Basin, the precipitation in the study area was mainly on the rise, this part of the area accounted for 81.2% of the total study area (the area that passed the 95% significance test accounted for 22.5% of the total), the rising rate mainly 1.2–10.8 mm/a, and the overall rising rate was mainly increased from the northwest to the southeast. Among them, except for a small part in the northeast and west of the Continental Basin, the rest of the areas belonged to the moderate fluctuation areas.

Frequency of ENSO events with different intensities

24 El Niño events and 41 La Niña events were identified in the study. It can be seen from Figure 4 that the frequency of El Niño events increased over time. The frequency of moderate El Niño event was the highest, accounting for about one-third of the total, followed by weak El Niño event and extremely weak El Niño event, both of which occurred five times in total. The frequency of La Niña was opposite to that of El Niño on the whole. The frequency of extremely strong La Niña event and moderate La Niña event was equal (both of them occurred 14 times), followed by weak La Niña event and strong La Niña event. The frequency of the extremely weak La Niña event was the lowest, which only occurred twice.
Figure 4

Intensity and frequency of ENSO events.

Figure 4

Intensity and frequency of ENSO events.

Close modal

Response relationship between precipitation and El Niño

Figure 5 showed the spatial distribution of precipitation anomaly percentage (PAP) under different intensities of El Niño events. Except for the northern part of the Continental Basin, when extremely strong and strong El Niño events occurred, the overall precipitation in the study area was distributed less in the north and more in the south. Among them, in the year with extremely strong El Niño events, the precipitation in the Huaihe River Basin, the Southwest Basin, and at the junction of the Continental Basin was approximately 30% more than the multi-year average. While the western and central parts of the Continental Basin and the middle reaches of the Yellow River Basin were the opposite. The areas with more precipitation in the year when strong El Niño events occurred were mainly concentrated in the Yangtze River Basin, the Pearl River Basin, the Southeast Basin, and the Southwest Basin. Among them, the precipitation in some areas of the Southwest Basins was 30% more than the multi-year average. In the year when moderate and weak El Niño events occurred, the areas with less precipitation accounted for approximately 70% of the total. Among them, in the year with moderate El Niño events, the precipitation was 10% less than the multi-year average in the Continental Basin, the junction of the Haihe River Basin and Songhua and Liaohe River Basin, etc. Precipitation in the rest of the basins was 4–7% less than the multi-year average. When weak El Niño events occurred, the areas with less precipitation were mainly concentrated in the Continental Basin, and the precipitation was roughly 70% of the multi-year average. When extremely weak El Niño events occurred, considering spatial distribution, the overall precipitation in the study area was more in the north and south and less in the middle. Among them, the precipitation in the southeastern Yangtze River Basin, the southern parts of the Southeast Basin, and the northeastern Songhua and Liaohe River Basin was 9–10% more than the multi-year average. The precipitation in the Yellow River Basin, the central and eastern part of the Continental Basin was 12–14% less than the multi-year average, and the precipitation in the rest of the areas was basically unchanged (the absolute value of PAP was mostly less than 5%).
Figure 5

Percentage change in precipitation under the premise of El Niño occurred with different intensities.

Figure 5

Percentage change in precipitation under the premise of El Niño occurred with different intensities.

Close modal

Response relationship between precipitation and La Niña

Figure 6 shows the spatial distribution of PAP under different intensities of La Niña events. It can be seen from the figure that in the year with extremely strong La Niña events, the areas with less precipitation in the study area accounted for 64.3% of the total, which was mainly distributed in the Continental Basin, the Yellow River Basin, the Songhua and Liaohe River Basin, the Southeast Basins, the Pearl River Basin, and other areas. The precipitation in the northwest and middle of the Continental Basin and the Pearl River Basin decreased by 6–14%, the precipitation in the rest of the areas decreased by 5%. The areas with increased precipitation accounted for roughly one-third of the study area, mainly concentrated in the Haihe River Basin, the Huaihe River Basin, the Southwest Basin, and the middle part of the Yangtze River Basin. The precipitation increased by nearly 10%. Except for more precipitation in the northern Songhua and Liaohe River Basin and less precipitation in the Haihe River Basin, the spatial distribution of the precipitation in the year with strong La Niña events was basically the same as that of extremely strong La Niña events. When moderate La Niña events occurred, the precipitation in the study area generally showed a ‘four-layered sandwich’ structure featuring less precipitation – more precipitation – less precipitation – more precipitation from north to south, the areas with more and less precipitation were almost equal (accounting for 52.9 and 47.1% of the total, respectively). Moreover, except for the western part of the Continental Basin, with roughly 12% more precipitation than the multi-year average in years with moderate La Niña events, the precipitation in the rest of the areas was nearly 10% more than the multi-year average. The precipitation in the study area was relatively low, when weak and extremely weak La Niña events occurred, the difference was that in the year when weak La Niña events occurred, precipitation would be reduced by more than 30% in nearly one-fifth of the study area, which was mainly concentrated in the Continental Basin. When extremely weak La Niña events occurred, except for the Southeast Basin and the lower reaches of the Yangtze River Basin (where the precipitation decreased by more than 10%), the absolute value of PAP in other areas was less than 5%.
Figure 6

Percentage change in precipitation under the premise of La Niña occurred with different intensities.

Figure 6

Percentage change in precipitation under the premise of La Niña occurred with different intensities.

Close modal

Correlation between precipitation and ENSO

Figure 7 shows the spatial distribution of the correlation between precipitation and El Niño events with different intensities. It can be seen from the figure that, except for the central part of the Yellow River Basin and northern Xinjiang, a close correlation between precipitation and extremely strong El Niño events was detected. The areas that passed the significance test at confidence levels of 90, 95, and 99% accounted for 9.3, 36.1, and 36.1% of the total study area, respectively. The areas that did not pass the significance test were mainly distributed in the middle of the Yellow River Basin and other areas, which only accounted for 18.5% of the total. The areas with a significant correlation between precipitation and strong El Niño events were mainly distributed in the Songhua and Liaohe River Basin, the Yellow River Basin, the Haihe River Basin, and the Southwest Basin. The areas that passed the significance test at a confidence level of 99% accounted for more than 50% of the total study area. Overall, the correlation was strong in the middle (approximately bounded by 150 and 800 mm isohyet) and gradually weakened toward the northwest and the southeast. As for the correlation coefficient between precipitation and moderate El Niño events, the areas that passed the significance test at confidence levels of 90, 95, and 99% accounted for 64.1, 4.7, and 22.1% of the total, respectively. The areas that did not pass the significance test accounted for 9.2% of the total, which was distributed in the eastern part of the Pearl River Basin and the western edge of the study area. In addition to the strong correlation between precipitation and weak El Niño events in the northern part of the Continental Basin, the correlation between precipitation and extremely weak El Niño events in the Southwestern River Basin was strong as well. The correlation coefficient between precipitation and weak or extremely weak El Niño events was low, and the areas that failed the significance test accounted for 75.6 and 87.6% of the total study area, respectively. In addition, precipitation in 7.5 and 5.8% of the areas was positively correlated with weak and extremely weak El Niño events, respectively. The former was mainly distributed in the southeast of the Yangtze River Basin, while the latter was concentrated in the Huaihe River Basin and its junction with the Yangtze River Basin.
Figure 7

Spatial distribution of correlation between precipitation and El Niño events with different intensities.

Figure 7

Spatial distribution of correlation between precipitation and El Niño events with different intensities.

Close modal
Figure 8 shows the spatial distribution of the correlation between precipitation and La Niña events with different intensities. It can be seen from the figure that the correlation between precipitation and extremely strong La Niña events was generally strong. 91.7% of the areas passed the significance test at a confidence level of 90%. Only 8.3% of the areas failed the significance test, which was mainly distributed in the southwest of the study area (within 8.3% of the areas, the correlation coefficient between precipitation and extremely strong La Niña events decreased from north to south as a whole, where precipitation and extremely strong La Niña events were positively correlated in the 1.03% of the areas and were negatively correlated in the rest of the areas) and the middle of the Yellow River Basin (the correlation was the weakest in the middle of the Yellow River Basin, and increased eastward and westward). The areas with a significant correlation between precipitation and strong La Niña events were mainly distributed in the Haihe River Basin, the Southeast Basin, and the middle of the Continental Basin and accounted for approximately 25.4% of the total study area, while the correlation in other areas was weak (did not pass the significance test). The correlation coefficient between precipitation and moderate, weak, or extremely weak La Niña events was generally low. Among them, the areas where precipitation strongly correlated with moderate La Niña events were mainly distributed in the southeast of the study area and accounted for roughly 8.5% of the total. The areas of precipitation strongly correlated with weak or extremely weak La Niña events were all concentrated in the Bohai Rim region (accounted for 7.3 and 10.9% of the total).
Figure 8

Spatial distribution of correlation between precipitation and La Niña events with different intensities.

Figure 8

Spatial distribution of correlation between precipitation and La Niña events with different intensities.

Close modal

Precipitation showed a downward trend before the mid-1930s, especially in the Songhua and Liaohe River Basin and the Continental Basin. Subsequently, the precipitation in the Southeast Basin and the Haihe River Basin all began to show a significant upward trend, and such a trend gradually expanded westward. In the 1950s, precipitation rose in the west and fell in the east in general, and this trend continued until the beginning of the 21st century. By 2007, except for the central part of the Continental Basin and other areas, which showed a downward trend, the precipitation in the study area mainly showed an upward trend. The precipitation tendency rate in the Haihe River Basin has changed significantly since 1991, and the rate of precipitation variation in the eastern monsoon region has accelerated (Liu et al. 2021). The precipitation in North China showed a downward trend from 1970 to 2000 (Zheng et al. 2020), which was basically consistent with the conclusion of this study. However, some scholars also pointed out that from 1979 to 2018, the precipitation in the Yarlung Zangbo River Basin showed an upward trend at all time scales (Zhang et al. 2022a, 2022b), and the precipitation in southwestern Tibet from 1901 to 2017 showed a fluctuating and decreasing trend (Li et al. 2022), which was somewhat different from this study, possibly due to different time scales and areas of the study.

In this study, 24 El Niño events and 41 La Niña events were identified; each type of event occurred once every 3 to 5 years on average. The frequency of ENSO events in the study was slightly lower than previous findings (Hao et al. 2016), which may be related to inconsistencies in the data sets used. The precipitation was generally lower when ENSO occurred (Gong & Wang 1999), and the type and intensity of events were all key influencing factors in the degree of variation in precipitation. For example, El Niño had a greater impact on precipitation than La Niña did. Specifically, when extremely strong El Niño events occurred, the areas with a relatively obvious change (including more than the muti-year average or less) in precipitation accounted for about 52.1% of the total study area (Figure 9(a)), whereas when extremely strong La Niña events occurred, the PAP was mostly within 10% (Figure 9(e)). Except for weak ENSO events (which were not shown in Figure 9), the impact of ENSO on precipitation decreased with intensity, which means extremely strong or strong ENSO events had a more significant impact on precipitation than moderate, or extremely weak events (Figure 9(a)–9(h)). This article was basically consistent with the conclusions that precipitation was usually increased (decreased) in some areas when El Niño (La Niña) events occurred (Maleski & Martinez 2018), and the precipitation in East Asia and North America was increased by approximately 20% in a year with El Niño events (Young et al. 2016).
Figure 9

Impact of El Niño or La Niña events with different intensities on precipitation.

Figure 9

Impact of El Niño or La Niña events with different intensities on precipitation.

Close modal

There were some similarities and differences in the correlation of precipitation with various ENSO events. Specifically, although precipitation was mainly negatively correlated with El Niño and La Niña at the same time and the strength of the correlation between precipitation and ENSO events was directly proportional to the intensity (that was, the correlation between precipitation and extremely strong/strong ENSO events was stronger than the correlation between precipitation and moderate/weak/extremely weak ENSO events), the correlation between precipitation and El Niño events was significantly stronger than the correlation between precipitation and La Niña events. The conclusion that different types of ENSO events had different effects on precipitation, and the intensity of ENSO events had a certain negative correlation with the level of drought and flood (Wang et al. 2016). When the intensity of EI Niño events increased, droughts in southwest China increased (Liu et al. 2019a, 2019b). All these conclusions were basically consistent with this study.

ENSO may also indirectly influence precipitation by affecting tropical cyclones (Du et al. 2020), the Asian summer monsoon (Wu et al. 2021), and others. Some scholars have also suggested that both the rearrangement of convection centers in the Walker circulation and the changes in the monsoon system during ENSO events may induce large precipitation anomalies in most parts of the world (Dai & Wigley 2000). The impact mechanism of ENSO on precipitation needs to be further studied in the future.

The study made a detailed analysis of the temporal and spatial variation features of precipitation in China and its relationship with ENSO, which had certain significance not only for revealing the temporal and spatial variations of precipitation in China and the correlation between such features and ENSO, but also for the improvement of the ecological environment and disaster prevention. However, there were several shortcomings. For example, the research method and data set used were not comprehensive, the study showed that wavelet coherence analysis is one of the best choices to achieve correlations in a time–frequency space (Araghi et al. 2017). Gridded precipitation products can be applied as an alternative, when precipitation records are not available, and multi-source gridded precipitation products had higher accuracy (Alireza et al. 2021). In the future, the response relationship between precipitation and ENSO should be compared and analyzed based on multiple data sets by using a combination of linear and non-linear methods at the same time.

The results showed that the precipitation in the study area was mainly on a downward trend before the mid-1930s, and then turned upward. In the 1950s, the precipitation generally showed a distribution of rising in the west and falling in the east, and this trend continued until the early 21st century. By 2007, except for the central part of the Continental Basin, the overall trend was mainly upward. In this study, 65 ENSO events were identified, including 24 El Niño events and 41 La Niña events. The precipitation was generally less when ENSO occurred. However, there were differences in the type and intensity of the events. For example, El Niño had a greater impact on precipitation than La Niña did, and extremely strong or strong El Niño/La Niña events had a more significant impact than moderate, or extremely weak ones. The correlation between precipitation and El Niño or La Niña events had some similarities and differences. For example, precipitation was mainly negatively correlated with El Niño and La Niña at the same time, and both correlations were proportional to intensity, but the correlation between precipitation and El Niño was significantly stronger than that of La Niña.

This research was funded by the Technology-Planning Project of Inner Mongolia (2020GG0074) and the Inner Mongolia Science Foundation (2020MS05054).

All relevant data are included in the paper or its Supplementary Information.

The authors declare there is no conflict.

Araghi, A., Jaghargh, M. R., Maghrebi, M., Martinez, C. J., Fraisse, C. W., Olesen, J. E. & Hoogenboom, G.
2021
Investigation of satellite-related precipitation products for modeling of rainfed wheat production systems
.
Agricultural Water Management
258
,
107222
.
Araghi
A.
,
Mousavi-Baygi
M.
,
Adamowski
J.
&
Martinez
C.
2017
Association between three prominent climatic teleconnections and precipitation in Iran using wavelet coherence
.
International Journal of Climatology
37
(
6
),
2809
2830
.
Chai
R. F.
2022
Attribution, Prediction and Economic and Social Impacts of Global Dryness Based on CMIP6 Model Results
.
Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology, Nanjing
.
Chen
D. K.
&
Lian
T.
2020
Frontier of El Niño-Southern Oscillation research
.
Chinese Science Bulletin
65
(
35
),
4001
4003
.
Chen
X.
,
Wang
S. S.
,
Hu
Z. Y.
,
Zhou
Q. M.
&
Hu
Q.
2018
Spatiotemporal characteristics of seasonal precipitation and their relationships with ENSO in Central Asia during 1901–2013
.
Journal of Geographical Sciences
28
(
9
),
1341
1368
.
Christine
C.
&
Scott
P.
2016
Modelled impact of global warming on ENSO-driven precipitation changes in the tropical Pacific
.
Climate Dynamics
47
(
3–4
),
1303
1323
.
Dai
A. G.
&
Wigley
T. M. L.
2000
Global patterns of ENSO-induced precipitation
.
Geophysical Research Letters
27
(
9
),
1283
1286
.
Deng
H. J.
,
Guo
B.
,
Cao
Y.
,
Chen
Z. S.
,
Zhang
Y. Q.
,
Chen
X. W.
,
Gao
L.
,
Chen
Y.
&
Liu
M. B.
2020
Spatial and temporal patterns of daytime and nighttime precipitation in China during 1961–2016
.
Geographical Research
39
(
10
),
2415
2426
.
Du
X. J.
,
Hendy
I.
,
Hinnov
L.
, Brown, E., Schimmelmann, A. & Pak, D.
2020
Interannual southern California precipitation variability during the common Era and the ENSO teleconnection
.
Geophysical Research Letters
47
(
1
),
e2019GL085891
.
Gong
D. Y.
&
Wang
S. W.
1999
Impacts of ENSO on rainfall of global land and China
.
Chinese Science Bulletin
44
(
9
),
852
857
.
Hao
Z. X.
,
Liu
K. B.
,
Zhang
X. Z.
,
Li
M. Q.
&
Zheng
J. Y.
2016
Relationship between ENSO episode and the spatial pattern of precipitation in eastern China as simulated in CESM control experiment
.
Journal of Natural Resources
31
(
12
),
1984
1994
.
Jia
Y. Q.
&
Zhang
B.
2020
Correlation analysis of variation of Dry-wet climate and ENSO in northern China during 1960–2017
.
Scientia Geographica Sinica
40
(
12
),
2115
2124
.
Jonaitis
J. A.
,
Perry
L. B.
,
Soulé
P. T.
,
Thaxton
C.
,
Andrade-Flores
M. F.
,
Vargas
T. I.
&
Ticona
L.
2021
Spatiotemporal patterns of ENSO-precipitation relationships in the tropical Andes of southern Peru and Bolivia
.
International Journal of Climatology
41
(
8
),
4061
4076
.
Lee
J. H.
&
Julien
P. Y.
2016
Teleconnections of the ENSO and south Korean precipitation patterns
.
Journal of Hydrology
534
,
237
250
.
Li
X. Y.
&
Zhai
P. M.
2000
On indices and indicators of ENSO episodes
.
Acta Meteorologica Sinica
58
(
1
),
102
109
.
Li
Y.
,
Jin
T. T.
,
Gao
B. L.
,
Zhang
Y. X.
&
Gong
J.
2022
Spatio-temporal variation of climate and its potential productivity in the Southwest Tibet Plateau during 1901–2017
.
Journal of Natural Resources
37
(
7
),
1918
1934
.
Liguori
G.
,
McGregor
S.
,
Singh
M.
,
Arblaster
J.
&
Lorenzo
E. D.
2022
Revisiting ENSO and IOD Contributions to Australian Precipitation
.
Geophysical Research Letters
49
(
1
),
e2021GL094295
.
Liu
J.
,
Wang
H.
,
Lu
E.
&
Kumar
A.
2019a
Decadal modulation of East China winter precipitation by ENSO
.
Climate Dynamics
52
(
12
),
7209
7223
.
Liu
L.
,
Xu
Z. X.
&
Yang
X. J.
2019b
Relationship between drought/flood and ENSO events in southwest China
.
Resources Science
41
(
11
),
2144
2153
.
Liu
Y. L.
,
Hua
Y.
,
Zhou
H. C.
,
Ye
L.
,
Wang
G. Q.
,
Jin
J. L.
&
Bao
Z. X.
2021
Precipitation variation and trend projection in the eastern monsoon region of China since 1470
.
Advances in Water Science
33
(
1
),
1
14
.
Ma
L.
,
Wang
J. R.
,
Liu
T. X.
,
Huang
X.
,
Liu
D. H.
&
Li
H. Y.
2016
Response relationship between vegetation and climate factors in horqin sandy land from 2000 to 2012
.
Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery
47
(
4
),
162
172
.
Nalley
D.
,
Adamowski
J.
,
Biswas
A.
,
Gharabaghi
B.
&
Hu
W.
2019
A multiscale and multivariate analysis of precipitation and streamflow variability in relation to ENSO, NAO and PDO
.
Journal of Hydrology
574
,
288
307
.
Omar
L. C.
,
Mariano
N. C.
,
Alberto
G.
&
Gabriel
E. G. G.
2020
Regional precipitation teleconnected with PDO-AMO-ENSO in northern Mexico
.
Theoretical and Applied Climatology
140
(
1
),
667
681
.
Pan
D. R.
2022
Influence Factors of NDVI Change and Evaluation of Grassland Ecological Service Function
.
Lanzhou Jiaotong University
.
Peng
S. Z.
2019
1-km Monthly Precipitation Dataset for China (1901–2020)
.
National Tibetan Plateau Data Center
.
Rahman
A. S. A.
,
Sandi
A. W.
,
Sudiana
M. M.
,
Wayan
A.
,
Nyoman
M.
,
Wayan
K.
,
Ni Wayan
E.
,
Wayan
N.
&
Nyoman
S.
2014
Observation of spatial patterns on the rainfall response to ENSO and IOD over Indonesia using TRMM multisatellite precipitation analysis (TMPA)
.
International Journal of Climatology
34
(
15
),
3825
3839
.
Ropelewski
C. F.
&
Halpert
M. S.
1987
Global and regional scale precipitation patterns associated with the El Niño/Southern Oscillation
.
Monthly Weather Review
115
(
8
),
1606
1626
.
Saleem
A.
,
Awange
J. L.
,
Kuhn
M.
,
John
B.
&
Hu
K.
2021
Impacts of extreme climate on Australia's green cover (2003–2018): a MODIS and mascon probe
.
Science of The Total Environment
766
,
142567
.
Shang
S. S.
,
Lian
L. S.
,
Ma
T.
,
Zhang
K.
&
Han
T.
2018
Spatiotemporal variation of temperature and precipitation in northwest China in recent 54 years
.
Arid Zone Research
35
(
1
),
68
76
.
Shimizu
M. H.
,
Ambrizzi
T.
&
Liebmann
B.
2017
Extreme precipitation events and their relationship with ENSO and MJO phases over northern South America
.
International Journal of Climatology
37
(
6
),
2977
2989
.
Souza
I. P.
,
Andreoli
R. V.
,
Kayano
M. T.
,
Vargas
F. F.
,
Cerón
W. L.
,
Martins
J. A.
,
Freitas
E.
&
Souza
R. A. F.
2021
Seasonal precipitation variability modes over South America associated to El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and non-ENSO components during the 1951–2016 period
.
International Journal of Climatology
41
(
8
),
4321
4338
.
Torbenson
M. C. A.
,
Stahle
D. W.
,
Howard
I. M.
,
Burnette
J. D.
,
Villanueva-Díaz
J.
,
Cook
E. R.
&
Griffin
D.
2019
Multidecadal modulation of the ENSO teleconnection to precipitation and tree growth over subtropical North America
.
Paleoceanography and Paleoclimatology
34
(
5
),
886
900
.
Wang
Y.
,
Zhang
Q.
,
Zhang
S.
&
Chen
X. H.
2016
Spatial and temporal characteristics of precipitation in the Huaihe River Basin and its response to ENSO events
.
Scientia Geographica Sinica
36
(
1
),
128
134
.
Wang
T.
,
Li
S. S.
,
Yan
J. P.
&
He
J. P.
2022
Spatio-temporal variation of summer precipitation in China based on ENSO development process
.
Journal of Natural Resources
37
(
3
),
803
815
.
Wen
N.
,
Liu
Z. Y.
&
Li
L.
2019
Direct ENSO impact on East Asian summer precipitation in the developing summer
.
Climate Dynamics
52
(
11
),
6799
6815
.
Wu
X. B.
,
Li
G.
,
Jiang
W. P.
,
Long
S. M.
&
Lu
B.
2021
Asymmetric relationship between ENSO and the tropical Indian ocean summer SST anomalies
.
Journal of Climate
34
(
14
),
5955
5969
.
Young
M. Y.
,
Jae
H. P.
,
Soon-Il
A.
,
Wang
B.
&
Luo
X.
2016
Mean sea surface temperature changes influence ENSO-related precipitation changes in the mid-latitudes
.
Nature Communications
12
(
1
),
1
9
.
Zhang
Y.
,
Zhou
W.
,
Wang
X.
,
Wang
X.
,
Zhang
R. H.
,
Li
Y. N.
&
Gan
J.
2022a
IOD, ENSO, and seasonal precipitation variation over Eastern China
.
Atmospheric Research
270
,
106042
.
Zhang
Y. H.
,
Liu
C. M.
,
Liang
K.
&
Liu
J. X.
2022b
Spatio-temporal variation of precipitation in the Yarlung Zangbo river basin
.
Acta Geographica Sinica
77
(
3
),
603
618
.
Zheng
J. Y.
,
Zhang
X. Z.
,
Liu
Y.
&
Hao
Z. X.
2020
The assessment on hydroclimatic changes of different regions in China at multi-scale during the past millennium
.
Acta Geographica Sinica
75
(
7
),
1420
1432
.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Licence (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0), which permits copying and redistribution for non-commercial purposes with no derivatives, provided the original work is properly cited (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).