Several commonly used statistical methods for fingerprint identification in microbial source tracking (MST) were examined to assess the effectiveness of pattern-matching algorithms to correctly identify sources. Although numerous statistical methods have been employed for source identification, no widespread consensus exists as to which is most appropriate. A large-scale comparison of several MST methods, using identical fecal sources, presented a unique opportunity to assess the utility of several popular statistical methods. These included discriminant analysis, nearest neighbour analysis, maximum similarity and average similarity, along with several measures of distance or similarity. Threshold criteria for excluding uncertain or poorly matched isolates from final analysis were also examined for their ability to reduce false positives and increase prediction success. Six independent libraries used in the study were constructed from indicator bacteria isolated from fecal materials of humans, seagulls, cows and dogs. Three of these libraries were constructed using the rep-PCR technique and three relied on antibiotic resistance analysis (ARA). Five of the libraries were constructed using Escherichia coli and one using Enterococcus spp. (ARA). Overall, the outcome of this study suggests a high degree of variability across statistical methods. Despite large differences in correct classification rates among the statistical methods, no single statistical approach emerged as superior. Thresholds failed to consistently increase rates of correct classification and improvement was often associated with substantial effective sample size reduction. Recommendations are provided to aid in selecting appropriate analyses for these types of data.
Skip Nav Destination
Article navigation
Research Article|
December 01 2003
Assessment of statistical methods used in library-based approaches to microbial source tracking
Kerry J. Ritter;
1Southern California Coastal Water Research Project, Westminster, CA 92863, USA
Tel: +1/7143729210 Fax: +1/8949699; E-mail: [email protected]
Search for other works by this author on:
Ethan Carruthers;
Ethan Carruthers
2Department of Soil, Water & Climate, University of Minnesota, St Paul, MN 55108, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
C. Andrew Carson;
C. Andrew Carson
3Department of Veterinary Pathobiology, University of Missouri, Columbia, MO 65211, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
R. D. Ellender;
R. D. Ellender
4University of Southern Mississippi, Hattiesburg, MS 39406, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
Valerie J. Harwood;
Valerie J. Harwood
5Department of Biology, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL 33620, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
Kyle Kingsley;
Kyle Kingsley
6Applied-Maths, Inc., 512 East 11th Street, Suite 207, Austin, Texas 78701, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
Cindy Nakatsu;
Cindy Nakatsu
7Department of Agronomy, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907 USA
Search for other works by this author on:
Michael Sadowsky;
Michael Sadowsky
2Department of Soil, Water & Climate, University of Minnesota, St Paul, MN 55108, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
Brian Shear;
Brian Shear
3Department of Veterinary Pathobiology, University of Missouri, Columbia, MO 65211, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
Brian West;
... Show more
Brian West
6Applied-Maths, Inc., 512 East 11th Street, Suite 207, Austin, Texas 78701, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
John E. Whitlock;
John E. Whitlock
8Division of Math and Science, Hillsborough Community College, Tampa, FL 33614, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
Bruce A. Wiggins;
Bruce A. Wiggins
9Department of Biology, James Madison University, Harrisonburg, VA 22807, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
Jayson D. Wilbur
Jayson D. Wilbur
10Department of Mathematical Sciences, Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, MA 01609, USA
Search for other works by this author on:
J Water Health (2003) 1 (4): 209–223.
Citation
Kerry J. Ritter, Ethan Carruthers, C. Andrew Carson, R. D. Ellender, Valerie J. Harwood, Kyle Kingsley, Cindy Nakatsu, Michael Sadowsky, Brian Shear, Brian West, John E. Whitlock, Bruce A. Wiggins, Jayson D. Wilbur; Assessment of statistical methods used in library-based approaches to microbial source tracking. J Water Health 1 December 2003; 1 (4): 209–223. doi: https://doi.org/10.2166/wh.2003.0022
Download citation file: