Summary of resilience metrics solutions for WDS-III at three small ranges in the cost range of ≤$11 million
| Cost range . | Resilience metric . | # of Solutions . | Avg. cost ($) . | Avg. std. dev. of pipe sizes (mm) . | Norm. mean pipe size (mm) . | Avg. reliability . | Avg. pipe flows (GPM) . | Avg. nodal pressure head (m) . |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $6.8–7.2 M | NRI | 15 | $6,984,000 | 37.44 | 206.45 | 0.963 | 99.03 | 23.66 |
| PRI | 25 | $6,985,200 | 38.15 | 206.20 | 0.961 | 99.28 | 24.42 | |
| FE | 6 | $6,961,667 | 38.68 | 206.15 | 0.951 | 110.43 | 19.46 | |
| MRI | 11 | $6,998,182 | 42.72 | 206.60 | 0.963 | 99.68 | 24.20 | |
| RI | 24 | $7,017,083 | 39.04 | 207.01 | 0.965 | 100.22 | 24.46 | |
| $8.3–8.7 M | NRI | 10 | $8,549,000 | 30.81 | 248.01 | 0.968 | 99.98 | 28.08 |
| PRI | 9 | $8,505,556 | 37.90 | 245.14 | 0.970 | 100.8 | 29.33 | |
| FE | 2 | $8,450,000 | 39.80 | 244.12 | 0.964 | 123.70 | 24.11 | |
| MRI | 3 | $8,510,000 | 42.44 | 244.30 | 0.970 | 99.20 | 29.60 | |
| RI | 11 | $8,536,364 | 40.28 | 245.31 | 0.970 | 100.52 | 29.26 | |
| $10.2–10.6 M | NRI | 5 | $10,400,000 | 33.02 | 288.19 | 0.971 | 100.41 | 30.42 |
| PRI | 3 | $10,400,000 | 39.42 | 286.44 | 0.973 | 101.40 | 30.99 | |
| MRI | 2 | $10,350,000 | 42.77 | 285.19 | 0.973 | 100.34 | 31.21 | |
| RI | 5 | $10,400,000 | 41.94 | 286.99 | 0.973 | 100.65 | 31.09 |
| Cost range . | Resilience metric . | # of Solutions . | Avg. cost ($) . | Avg. std. dev. of pipe sizes (mm) . | Norm. mean pipe size (mm) . | Avg. reliability . | Avg. pipe flows (GPM) . | Avg. nodal pressure head (m) . |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $6.8–7.2 M | NRI | 15 | $6,984,000 | 37.44 | 206.45 | 0.963 | 99.03 | 23.66 |
| PRI | 25 | $6,985,200 | 38.15 | 206.20 | 0.961 | 99.28 | 24.42 | |
| FE | 6 | $6,961,667 | 38.68 | 206.15 | 0.951 | 110.43 | 19.46 | |
| MRI | 11 | $6,998,182 | 42.72 | 206.60 | 0.963 | 99.68 | 24.20 | |
| RI | 24 | $7,017,083 | 39.04 | 207.01 | 0.965 | 100.22 | 24.46 | |
| $8.3–8.7 M | NRI | 10 | $8,549,000 | 30.81 | 248.01 | 0.968 | 99.98 | 28.08 |
| PRI | 9 | $8,505,556 | 37.90 | 245.14 | 0.970 | 100.8 | 29.33 | |
| FE | 2 | $8,450,000 | 39.80 | 244.12 | 0.964 | 123.70 | 24.11 | |
| MRI | 3 | $8,510,000 | 42.44 | 244.30 | 0.970 | 99.20 | 29.60 | |
| RI | 11 | $8,536,364 | 40.28 | 245.31 | 0.970 | 100.52 | 29.26 | |
| $10.2–10.6 M | NRI | 5 | $10,400,000 | 33.02 | 288.19 | 0.971 | 100.41 | 30.42 |
| PRI | 3 | $10,400,000 | 39.42 | 286.44 | 0.973 | 101.40 | 30.99 | |
| MRI | 2 | $10,350,000 | 42.77 | 285.19 | 0.973 | 100.34 | 31.21 | |
| RI | 5 | $10,400,000 | 41.94 | 286.99 | 0.973 | 100.65 | 31.09 |