Skip to Main Content
Table 1

Feature comparison of selected MBR modelling studies using an integrated RIS model approach

Reference/Model featuresLee et al. (2002) Wintgens et al. (2003) Di Bella et al. (2008) Zarragoitia-González et al. (2008) Zarragoitia et al. (2009) Mannina et al. (2011) Sarioglu et al. (2012) Zuthi et al. (2012) Janus & Ulanicki (2016) Mannina et al. (2018a, b) 
Biological sub-model           
Biomass growth (e.g. XTSS       
ASM (SMP hybrid)   
SMP    
EPS         
Process sub-models           
Process control         
Energy       
Experimental set-up           
Laboratory-scale       
Pilot-scale       
Full-scale          
Short time series (<1 week)         
Long time series (>1 week)   
Calibration method           
Heuristic        
Stochastic (e.g. sensitivity analysis)        
Reference/Model featuresLee et al. (2002) Wintgens et al. (2003) Di Bella et al. (2008) Zarragoitia-González et al. (2008) Zarragoitia et al. (2009) Mannina et al. (2011) Sarioglu et al. (2012) Zuthi et al. (2012) Janus & Ulanicki (2016) Mannina et al. (2018a, b) 
Biological sub-model           
Biomass growth (e.g. XTSS       
ASM (SMP hybrid)   
SMP    
EPS         
Process sub-models           
Process control         
Energy       
Experimental set-up           
Laboratory-scale       
Pilot-scale       
Full-scale          
Short time series (<1 week)         
Long time series (>1 week)   
Calibration method           
Heuristic        
Stochastic (e.g. sensitivity analysis)        
Close Modal

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal