Total monetary benefits from water allocation using the bankruptcy rules.
| . | Province . | Crop production benefits, per cubic kilometer of water (million US$) . | Total benefits from water allocation (million US$) . |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proportionate rule (PRO) | Punjab | 153 | 12,768 |
| Sindh | 65 | 2,145 | |
| Baluchistan | 224 | 1,606 | |
| KPK | 249 | 1,571 | |
| Total | 18,090 | ||
| Constraint equal award rule (CEA) | Punjab | 153 | 10,546 |
| Sindh | 65 | 2,816 | |
| Baluchistan | 224 | 2,110 | |
| KPK | 249 | 2,062 | |
| Total | 17,534 | ||
| Constraint equal loss rule (CEL) | Punjab | 153 | 15,003 |
| Sindh | 65 | 2,459 | |
| Baluchistan | 224 | 0 | |
| KPK | 249 | 0 | |
| Total | 17,462 | ||
| Talmud rule (TAL) | Punjab | 153 | 14,326 |
| Sindh | 65 | 1,789 | |
| Baluchistan | 224 | 1,055 | |
| KPK | 249 | 1,031 | |
| Total | 18,201 | ||
| Piniles rule (PIN) | Punjab | 153 | 11,120 |
| Sindh | 65 | 2,575 | |
| Baluchistan | 224 | 2,110 | |
| KPK | 249 | 2,062 | |
| Total | 17,867 |
| . | Province . | Crop production benefits, per cubic kilometer of water (million US$) . | Total benefits from water allocation (million US$) . |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proportionate rule (PRO) | Punjab | 153 | 12,768 |
| Sindh | 65 | 2,145 | |
| Baluchistan | 224 | 1,606 | |
| KPK | 249 | 1,571 | |
| Total | 18,090 | ||
| Constraint equal award rule (CEA) | Punjab | 153 | 10,546 |
| Sindh | 65 | 2,816 | |
| Baluchistan | 224 | 2,110 | |
| KPK | 249 | 2,062 | |
| Total | 17,534 | ||
| Constraint equal loss rule (CEL) | Punjab | 153 | 15,003 |
| Sindh | 65 | 2,459 | |
| Baluchistan | 224 | 0 | |
| KPK | 249 | 0 | |
| Total | 17,462 | ||
| Talmud rule (TAL) | Punjab | 153 | 14,326 |
| Sindh | 65 | 1,789 | |
| Baluchistan | 224 | 1,055 | |
| KPK | 249 | 1,031 | |
| Total | 18,201 | ||
| Piniles rule (PIN) | Punjab | 153 | 11,120 |
| Sindh | 65 | 2,575 | |
| Baluchistan | 224 | 2,110 | |
| KPK | 249 | 2,062 | |
| Total | 17,867 |