Skip to Main Content

The silhouette analysis was again performed to obtain an accurate number of K-means clustering for the eight 5-year sub-periods in a similar way used for the 10-year sub-periods and the full-time period. Our analysis indicates that the cosine distance method gave the best result for the six 5-year sub-periods, including 1980–1984, 1985–1989,1990–1994, 1995–1999, 2000–2004, and 2015–2020 (Table 3). For the 2005–2009 and 2010–2014 sub-periods, however, the correlation distance method identified the cluster numbers more accurately.

Table 3

The silhouette analysis for the eight 5-year sub-periods with the resulting optimum distance method (highlighted in bold and italics)

5-year sub-periodsDistance methodSilhoutte informationCluster members
345678
1980–1984 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.342 0.298 0.295 0.271 0.273 0.255 
Number of negative value 5 10 14 13 
1985–1989 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.290 0.288 0.312 0.266 0.246 0.252 
Number of negative value 11 1 
1990–1994 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.276 0.295 0.315 0.325 0.299 0.307 
Number of negative value 10 11 10 11 5 
1995–1999 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.285 0.274 0.284 0.266 0.258 0.269 
Number of negative value 11 11 7 10 
2000–2004 Correlation Average silhouette value 0.228 0.281 0.321 0.285 0.312 0.263 
Number of negative value 26 23 12 15 8 
2005–2009 Correlation Average silhouette value 0.214 0.258 0.282 0.274 0.242 0.254 
Number of negative value 23 14 8 14 
2010–2014 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.247 0.255 0.265 0.268 0.258 0.241 
Number of negative value 15 10 8 11 13 
2015–2020 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.290 0.300 0.287 0.307 0.310 0.265 
Number of negative value 12 7 12 10 11 19 
5-year sub-periodsDistance methodSilhoutte informationCluster members
345678
1980–1984 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.342 0.298 0.295 0.271 0.273 0.255 
Number of negative value 5 10 14 13 
1985–1989 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.290 0.288 0.312 0.266 0.246 0.252 
Number of negative value 11 1 
1990–1994 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.276 0.295 0.315 0.325 0.299 0.307 
Number of negative value 10 11 10 11 5 
1995–1999 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.285 0.274 0.284 0.266 0.258 0.269 
Number of negative value 11 11 7 10 
2000–2004 Correlation Average silhouette value 0.228 0.281 0.321 0.285 0.312 0.263 
Number of negative value 26 23 12 15 8 
2005–2009 Correlation Average silhouette value 0.214 0.258 0.282 0.274 0.242 0.254 
Number of negative value 23 14 8 14 
2010–2014 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.247 0.255 0.265 0.268 0.258 0.241 
Number of negative value 15 10 8 11 13 
2015–2020 Cosine Average silhouette value 0.290 0.300 0.287 0.307 0.310 0.265 
Number of negative value 12 7 12 10 11 19 

Close Modal

or Create an Account

Close Modal
Close Modal