This article investigates the current institutional arrangement concerning water governance in Nainital, India, located in the Western Himalayas. It assesses the availability of water resources, the functioning of the supply system, and sheds light on the role of institutions in managing water resources, supply, and distribution. Through qualitative methods (such as focus group discussions and key informant interviews with officials from water management institutions, citizens, etc.) supplemented by a literature review, the study reveals a complex network of institutions and stakeholders involved in water management. This complexity results in overlapping jurisdictions, leading to accountability gaps and various issues. The study identifies that in Nainital, existing institutions operate independently, impacting water governance in terms of water supply, resources, and environmental aspects. Considering the fragile biophysical environment of Nainital, the study also recommends integration of nature-centric approaches into institutional frameworks, which can be helpful in improving the resilience of water systems and promoting sustainable water governance.

  • Issues and challenges in efficient water management.

  • Impact of overlapping and mismanagement of institutions on water supply, resources, and environment.

  • The integration of nature-centric approaches into institutional frameworks can be helpful in enhancing the effectiveness of water management authorities and improving environmental conditions.

Water is the most precious resource on the planet and is not just a public good but also a human right, as declared by the United Nations (UN) in 2010. Geographically, it is not equally distributed and can present significant challenges for management and equitable access because of the nature of its physical existence. Compared to other geographies and water systems, Himalayan mountain water and governance systems remain relatively less understood (Singh & Pandey, 2020). The Himalayan region, also known as the ‘Water Tower of Asia’, is richly endowed with water and provides an important regional lifeline for two billion people through water flows (hydropower) and other ecosystem services (Christopher et al., 2019), and despite this, governance of water in mountains and hills has not been studied well.

In most of the Himalayan countries like Bangladesh, India, Nepal, and Pakistan, the urban population is growing between 3 and 5% (Singh et al., 2019). Moreover, in provinces of these countries, most of the Himalayan cities are tourist destinations and host large floating populations during peak tourist season, challenging their carrying capacities in terms of providing clean water and sanitation (Shah & Kulkarni, 2015; Mondal & Roychowdhury, 2019; Ojha et al., 2019). These hill cities are facing population-driven scarcity, and due to increasing population pressure and changing water consumption behaviour, the challenge of keeping water consumption at a sustainable level is becoming difficult. The supply and demand gap ranges between 20 and 70% in the towns of the Himalayan region as a result of poor governance, lack of urban planning, in-migration, tourist influx, and climate-related risks and challenges (Ojha et al., 2020).

Good governance in water distribution and management is currently lacking in most hill towns due to multi-level conflicts (Shrestha et al., 2020). The Himalayan region's water governance is typified by hybrid formal–informal regimes, wherein informal institutions are prevalent at the local level and formal state institutions at the national and regional levels. However, the necessary cooperation and support between state and informal water management institutions is frequently observed to be absent (Christopher et al., 2019). Governance challenges and inefficient water utilities become much more critical for hilly and mountain regions as the sources of water are limited and the local geology hardly supports accessing groundwater unlike in the plains (Dame et al., 2019). Therefore, hill towns need to be viewed in the broader context of mountain waters, and all aspects related to water like resource management, supply system, and institutional arrangements need to be closely monitored.

The literature supports the fact that most of the time water crisis is caused by ‘governance crisis’ (UN World Water Report, 2016; Saleth, 2018). Water governance encompasses water management, and water management consists of two distinguishable but closely related concepts: water resources management, and water services. Water resource management entails the protection, use, development, conservation, and control of water resources to achieve social equity, economic development, and environmental sustainability. However, water services on the other hand entail the provision of water supply to users (potable and commercial use) as well as sanitation (Thompson et al., 2001). In other words, water management includes customary law, norms, and practices between institutions, groups, civil society, and private sector (Paavola, 2007), and for a comprehensive water management system, water institution analysis is essential.

Identically, the water institutional structure is composed of three institutional elements: water law, water policy, and water administration (Saleth & Dinar, 2004). The water law and policy require mutual adjustment and refinement over time for their successful execution, whereas water administration is supposed to implement water law and policies at the ground level within the set institutional framework. This analysis is crucial for developing nations (Saleth & Dinar, 2004; Pahl-Wostl et al., 2012; Akhmouch & Correia, 2016) as it directly affects agriculture, environment, urban and rural development, health, housing, as well as economic development (MacKay & Ashton, 2004).

India as a developing nation and one of the countries in the Himalayan region ranks as the second most populous (960 million) and the seventh largest (3.29 million km2) country in the world. Because of this increased population, the water insecurity has arisen, and situation has become worse due to the weak institutional system (Pandey et al., 2019). Water laws are essential for the efficient management, but in India, water laws are heavily fragmented and water-related legislations use piecemeal approaches and far less than comprehensive. The State governments have the jurisdiction over water (Saleth & Dinar, 1999; D'Souza, 2001) and several federal ministries and institutions function to manage it, which produces a rather complex management structure which hampers effective formulation and coordination of policy and often results in duplication, unclear responsibility, and non-accountability (Narain, 2000).

Among the various mid-sized Himalayan cities of India such as Shimla, Mussoorie, and Darjeeling, this study primarily focuses on Nainital. The study aimed to understand the current water resources and supply system of the city; identify the various institutions involved in water management; analyse their co-operative arrangements, roles, and responsibilities; and evaluate their impact on the effectiveness and efficiency of water governance in the city. In addition, the study also suggests incorporating nature-centric approaches into institutional frameworks. This integration can enhance the resilience of water systems and foster sustainable water governance.

As Nainital shares similarities with many other mid-sized Himalayan cities in terms of ecological resources, the results drawn from this study can serve as a starting point for improving water governance in other Himalayan cities facing similar kinds of water challenges like Shimla, Mussoorie, and Darjeeling in India; Dharan and Dhulikhel in Nepal; Gilgit and Quetta in Pakistan; and Rangamati and Banderban in Bangladesh.

Nainital, a popular hill station, has long been revered for its stunning beauty. The city is home to the breathtaking, 48-hectare Naini Lake, which not only adds to its charm but also serves as a crucial water source for both residents and tourists. However, in recent decades, Nainital has faced significant environmental changes, particularly in its hydrological cycle, due to rapid urbanization, poorly planned development, and a burgeoning tourist population (Singh, 2021). The sustainability of Naini Lake is now at risk due to excessive water extraction and human activities (Divyanjali, et al., 2023). In addition, the city's aging water distribution network, originally designed for a smaller population, is struggling to meet the current demand, resulting in an average water availability of 92 l per capita per day, below the Indian Government standard. This dual challenge of stressed water resources and water scarcity for residents underscores the urgent need for effective water governance in Nainital.

About study area

Nainital is situated in the Western Himalayan region, Uttarakhand, India (Figure 1). It is located at 29°24′ N latitude and 79°29′ E longitude and separates the Siwaliks from the Lesser Himalaya. The kidney bean-shaped Naini lake is the most prominent feature of the town. The elevation at the lake level is 1938 amsl (above mean sea level). The city is spread over approximately 11.73 km2 area and is divided into 15 municipal wards. Nainital attracts on average about 72,650 daily visitors, of which 90% stay overnight (UUSDA, 2020). The population of the city experienced significant growth from 2011 to 2020, with estimates indicating a surge of nearly 50%, reaching approximately 60,000 residents by 2020 compared to 41,377 recorded in the 2011 census (UIRUDP, 2021). Since then, the population is likely to have increased.
Fig. 1

Location map of Nainital nestled in Uttarakhand, India, within the Western Himalayas.

Fig. 1

Location map of Nainital nestled in Uttarakhand, India, within the Western Himalayas.

Close modal

Nainital experiences annual rainfall around 1903 mm, and in general, there is an increase in the lake water level with rainfall. There are five sluice gates towards the lower end of the lake to regulate the water level in the lake particularly during the rainy season. Excess water is discharged from these gates, which then joins a river downstream.

Identification of existing water institutions of Nainital

In India, there are many water institutions involved in managing the three institutional components, i.e., water law, policy, and administration (Chopra & Ramchandran, 2021), but recognizing the complexity of Nainital's water governance and for a meaningful focused evaluation, only concerned institutions were selected for the study.

To assess the current institutional framework and its implications, key stakeholders and institutions were mapped. Formal institutions include Uttarakhand Jal Sansthan, Uttarakhand Pay Jal Nigam, Municipal Authority, Irrigation Department, National Lake Region Special Area Development Authority, Public Works Department (PWD), Forest Department, and Administrative Department, which play leading roles in water services. In addition, other entities such as the Asian Development Bank (ADB) and SWAJAL are also involved in water services. Informal institutions encompass non-governmental organizations, civil society groups, and community-led groups.

Data collection

The methodology for this research paper involved a multifaceted approach to data collection. Primary data were gathered through two focus group discussions (FGDs) and 10 key informant interviews (KIIs). The FGDs were conducted with a diverse group including informed citizens, community leaders, boatmen, taxi owners, local vendors, and tourists. On the other hand, KIIs were conducted with a range of stakeholders including an academician as a subject expert, members from the hospitality industry (hotels and restaurants), trade associations (shop owners, petty traders, and vendors), local civil society, and officials from various departments such as Uttarakhand Jal Sansthan, Municipal Authority, and other concerned departments involved in managing the water in Nainital. The majority of participants were graduates, aged between 18 and 50 years. Both the KIIs and FGDs were audio recorded with the consent of the interviewees.

To ensure a comprehensive understanding, the theme of the questionnaire was based on water availability, resources, supply and distribution, management issues, and challenges. Secondary data were gathered through a comprehensive literature review and synthesis, including grey literature such as news articles and reports. Sustainable, nature-centric approaches were extracted through the literature survey and presented with the involvement of the respective institutions to derive the most suitable and sustainable water management for the study site.

Water resource availability

Lakes and springs have been and continue to be major sources of water supply in the hilly region of the Himalayas (Chhimwal et al., 2022). In the case of Nainital, the lake is the main source of drinking water. It is fed directly or indirectly by 79 km of drainage network in its catchment area. The catchment area is delineated by many faults and fractures coinciding with a surface drainage system. The three major water resources of the Nainital are as follows: (1) Naini lake, (2) Sukhatal (a sub-catchment of Naini lake), and (3) springs. Thus, the water used by the Nainital city is a mix of surface and ground water, but the majority is contributed through ground water extraction. As per the information shared by Jal Sansthan of Nainital, at present, 15 tubewells are installed, 11 are at lakeside, while 4 are installed on the lake bed of Sukhatal. These tubewells are now the main sources of water for Nainital and produce 8.0 mld (million litre per day) water per day, while the rest 0.167 mld is drawn from the springs.

Water supply system

An Environmental and Social Systems Assessment (2017) reveals that the state has implemented several water supply schemes to harness water from streams, rivers, and lakes. In Nainital, the city historically depended on a piped water supply system that drew water from a local spring called Pardadhara. Since then, the system has gradually expanded over time. Originally, this was a gravity-fed system. Dash et al., (2008) described a comprehensive description of this development of Nainital's water supply.

Lake water, which is drawn out from wells and pumps adjoining the lake body, undergoes a process of natural filtration. To supply water to residential areas at higher elevations, it is essential to pump water from both the Sukhatal sub-catchment and groundwater sources. Four water pump houses are used to distribute water around the 20 water supply zones of the city. These water pumps are commonly referred to as (1) Main pump house, (2) Lakeside pump house, (3) Sukhatal pump house, and (4) Fasi-ka-gadhera pump house, and the quantities of pumped water from the pump house are 3.00, 2.50, 1.76, and 0.74 mld, respectively (Figure 2).
Fig. 2

Illustration of ward wise water supply system of Nainital.

Fig. 2

Illustration of ward wise water supply system of Nainital.

Close modal

Institutions responsible for water management

Good water management often reflects a symbiotic relationship between formal and informal institutions, where both play crucial roles and are interdependent (Charles, et al., 2005), but Nainital's institutional system is primarily characterized by the dominance of formal institutions and a limited presence of informal ones. The water supply of Nainital is mainly operated and maintained by Uttarakhand Jal Sansthan (UJS), working under Department of Drinking Water & Sanitation (DDWS), Government of Uttarakhand (GoU). UJS undertakes small-budget capital works and is responsible for planning, survey, DPR (Detailed Project Report) preparation and execution of water supply and sewerage projects. Large capital works and overall planning are carried out by another corporation, Uttarakhand Pey Jal Nigam (UPJN), which also comes under DDWS. Although it is supposed to be a municipal function, Nainital Nagar Palika Parishad (NNPP) is not involved in conventional municipal functions such as water supply, sewerage, etc. These functions are in the hands of state agencies (CDP: Nainital, 2007).

There are some other departments that are not directly or significantly involved in the Water Supply & Sanitation (WSS) sector but nevertheless play an important oversight, regulatory, or financing role. In Nainital, the Irrigation Department played an important role in the lake-related matters. The maintenance responsibility of the lake was handed over to the Irrigation Department from PWD. Outflow from the lake through five sluice gates was controlled by the PWD department until 2017, but the charge was handed over to Irrigation Department in 2018. Another authority that plays an important role in relation to lake water is Nainital Lake Region Special Area Development Authority (NLRSDA). It implements the restoration works and has the power to restrict constructions in and around the lake, which is clearly a part of Naini lake catchment.

Other agencies, depending on their geographical jurisdiction, are also involved in the delivery of WSS services. Some like Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) and SWAJAL may be directly involved in the implementation or the management of drinking water supply and sanitation schemes, while some others like Social Welfare, Forest Department and ADB either provide specific support/funds or provide clearances for specific schemes and projects. All these facts indicate that with time many institutions have emerged in the urban environment of Nainital. Table 1 presents detailed information related to roles and responsibilities of the institutions responsible for the water management in Nainital.

Table 1

Roles and responsibilities of different institutions involved in water management in Nainital.

InstitutionsRoles and responsibilities
Water Management Authority UJS – Water conservation measures, policy, laws, and tariff (in consultation with District Administration); use of efficient appliances; scheduling of water supply; public awareness; separating the rainwater from the sewer line of the houses located in the city and connecting it to the main drains etc.
UJN – Construction and maintenance of tertiary level sewage treatment plants and disposal of the treatment effluent into the drains. 
Nainital Nagar Palika Parishad (NNPP) Cleaning of lake; solid waste management; proper provision and management of public facilities; complete ban on disposal of domestic waste in drains and arrangement of its disposal. 
Irrigation Department Work related to constructions and maintenance of 62 drains leading to Naini lake, Sukhatal, and the regulating structure; lake water quality monitoring and display of water level; formulation of guidelines for outlet gate operation; disconnecting rainwater drains from sewers. 
Nainital Lake Region Special Area Development Authority (NLRSDA) Check on unauthorized construction and prevention of disposal of construction debris into drains. 
Forest Department Notification of wetland; Rain Water Harvesting plan in the catchment; catchment area treatment; checking soil erosion in the catchment. 
Public Works Department (PWD) Work related to operation, maintenance, and cleaning of road side drains and related structures; construction of parking lots (in consultation with the District Administration and Nagar Palika Parishad). 
District Magistrate Office (DMO) In the case of Nainital, DMO provides legal permission to work on the lake. Any person or organization/civic society/institution must take permission of DM before starting any work related to the lake. 
InstitutionsRoles and responsibilities
Water Management Authority UJS – Water conservation measures, policy, laws, and tariff (in consultation with District Administration); use of efficient appliances; scheduling of water supply; public awareness; separating the rainwater from the sewer line of the houses located in the city and connecting it to the main drains etc.
UJN – Construction and maintenance of tertiary level sewage treatment plants and disposal of the treatment effluent into the drains. 
Nainital Nagar Palika Parishad (NNPP) Cleaning of lake; solid waste management; proper provision and management of public facilities; complete ban on disposal of domestic waste in drains and arrangement of its disposal. 
Irrigation Department Work related to constructions and maintenance of 62 drains leading to Naini lake, Sukhatal, and the regulating structure; lake water quality monitoring and display of water level; formulation of guidelines for outlet gate operation; disconnecting rainwater drains from sewers. 
Nainital Lake Region Special Area Development Authority (NLRSDA) Check on unauthorized construction and prevention of disposal of construction debris into drains. 
Forest Department Notification of wetland; Rain Water Harvesting plan in the catchment; catchment area treatment; checking soil erosion in the catchment. 
Public Works Department (PWD) Work related to operation, maintenance, and cleaning of road side drains and related structures; construction of parking lots (in consultation with the District Administration and Nagar Palika Parishad). 
District Magistrate Office (DMO) In the case of Nainital, DMO provides legal permission to work on the lake. Any person or organization/civic society/institution must take permission of DM before starting any work related to the lake. 

Identified issues and challenges in efficient water management

Issue of institutional overlapping

Regardless of whether the area is hilly or flat, the overlapping mandates of institutions serve as a contributing factor to the failure of water management (Nleya, 2005). After exploring the roles and responsibilities of institutions of Nainital, we also found substantial interconnections among stakeholders. The diagram vividly depicts the overlapping roles of various institutions involved in water management in Nainital.

It is clear from Figure 3 that multiple institutions with overlapping mandates and unclear roles are involved in the construction, operation, and maintenance of water management schemes. Figure 3 also explains that how these institutions oversee various aspects of water management, including conservation, restoration of water bodies, water supply, distribution, and stormwater management. However, due to a lack of proper institutional governance and coordination, there is duplication of activities. This situation not only affects the efficiency of these institutions but also raises questions about their accountability and risk responsibility. Below are some examples of overlapping responsibilities identified during the study.
  • (1) Both Jal Sansthan and Jal Nigam come under the Drinking Water Supply and Sanitation Department and take care of water supply and sewage management, respectively.

  • (2) Usually, PWD takes care of road construction and other public utility works but here also expected to evolve measures for storm water management.

  • (3) Similarly, NNPP has been made administratively accountable with building by-laws to prevent unregulated construction on catchment areas. In addition to this, NLRSDA also has the power to restrict constructions in and around the lake catchment.

  • (4) Along with its regular work, the Forest Department also has to look after the restoration and conservation measures of water resources coming in the lake catchment area.

  • (5) The Irrigation Department manages the drainage system and also controls the lake level data and outflow from the lake.

  • (6) Apart from this, just to keep the check on each movement related to the lake, one has to take permission from District Magistrate Office (DMO) before starting any work related to it.

  • (7) Finally, some less recognised informal institutions are also involved at their level and style, as every citizen of India has the fundamental right to improve and protect the natural environment including forests, rivers, and lakes.

Fig. 3

Institutional landscaping: functions and interconnections.

Fig. 3

Institutional landscaping: functions and interconnections.

Close modal

Challenges in efficient water management

Apart from institutional overlapping, extreme climatic conditions and fragile landscape are significant challenges for sustainable water supply in this beautiful city (Chauhan et al., 2021). These factors, compounded by anthropogenic pressures, place significant stress on the city's water resources (Singh & Gopal, 2002; Purushothaman et al., 2012; Raghav, 2020). Officials responsible for Nainital's water institutions are struggling to conserve, manage, and distribute water effectively with the limited carrying capacity of the lake and springs. The city's rapid population growth has further strained water resources, leading to the increased demand and more water abstraction. Currently, Naini Lake caters to 76% of the total water demand. In other words, the constantly changing conditions in ecologically fragile sloping landscape, along with uncertainties related to climate change and natural disasters, exacerbate the complexities of the existing water governance of the city.

Impact of institutional overlapping

Research indicates that well-designed water institutions not only play a crucial role in promoting sustainable water use, distribution, and management across different scales (Saleth & Dinar, 2008) but also help in determining the interaction between social and natural systems (Ostrom, 1990) and providing the foundation for effective coordination and management of water resources. Contrary to this, a lack of institutional action poses a significant threat to the future of urban water security (Pandey et al., 2019). Moreover, factors such as resource management, inappropriate institutional arrangements, and bureaucratic inertia undermine the effective governance of water in many parts of the world (UNDP-SIWI Water Governance Facility).

As we transition from an era of abundance to an era of scarcity, there is a growing global focus on institutional arrangements related to water supply, distribution, and resource management (Saleth, 2004). The findings of a study suggest that the water challenges in Nainital are not solely due to ‘scarcity’ but also stem from ‘mismanagement’, despite the presence of numerous formal and informal water institutions in the city. The current institutional framework in Nainital is struggling due to unclear mandates, as the transition of functions has not been fully completed. Analysis indicates that the multitude of water institutions and city authorities are not effectively contributing to sustainable water management, which is causing a significant impact on the city's water governance and the complexities of institutional overlapping exacerbate this issue. Particularly in the context of Nainital, this overlap is significantly affecting various aspects. Some of the key impacts are described in the following subsections.

Impact on lake

The impact of institutional overlapping on water governance is profound due to the situation surrounding the ownership and maintenance of the lake. The overlapping institutions have resulted in fragmentation and confusion in decision-making processes, particularly regarding the management of the lake.

According to Sengupta et al. (2017), the municipality is the owner of the lake, feeder channels, and catchments, but there has been a notable lack of effort from the municipality to conserve the lake. This has led to a situation where blame is passed between municipality and PWD, each entity accusing the other of neglecting their responsibilities. The lack of clarity in ownership has created a scenario where the lake's health is increasingly at risk. In response to growing concerns, maintenance responsibilities for the lake were shifted from the PWD to the irrigation department (Singh, 2017). However, this has created a disjointed system where one department owns the lake, while another is responsible for its maintenance. If these conflicts and issues between the departments are not addressed promptly and effectively, the lake will remain under significant threat, highlighting the detrimental impact of institutional overlapping on water governance.

Impact on water services

Under normal conditions, providing adequate water to residents is challenging, but during times of peak tourist seasons, the situation worsens in many lower Himalayan cities (Ojha et al., 2020). This issue is particularly acute in Nainital (Santoshi & Roy, 2019). Residents of Nainital receive a limited water supply in peak tourist season. During our investigation, we found that the city's water supply network is suffering from technical glitches like poor maintenance and broken pipes and leakages. Despite the involvement of 12 formal and informal institutions in water management in Nainital, Jal Sansthan is entrusted with the responsibility of ensuring continuous domestic water supply, while UPJN oversees the installation, construction, and maintenance of water pipes. This division of responsibility leads to mismanagement because these two bodies often work in isolation, rather than in convergence. Thus, both the departments have a particular role in water distribution, but risk responsibility comes in the share of Jal Sansthan only. It is imperative to address this mismanagement promptly to reduce the risk to water supply security in Nainital. Overall, the overlapping institutions in Nainital are leading to significant consequences for water services, especially considering the additional strain from the floating tourist population.

Impact on water resource management

This is widely acknowledged that over-abstraction of water and construction in the catchment area pose significant threats to water resources (Park et al., 2021). The study highlights the repercussions of institutional overlapping on water resource management, clearly evident in the challenges faced by the Naini Lake and springs present within the city. Our primary concern regarding the resource management is that there is an absence of single responsible institution for the strategic planning and management of water resources in Nainital. The task of regulating the unauthorized construction in the catchment area and enforcement of building by-laws around water resources is divided between two institutions, NLRSDA and NNPP. Although it was announced during policy regulation that the Uttarakhand Water Resources Management and Regulatory Commission (UWRMRC) would be formed to manage and restore water resources in the state, but nothing substantial is happening at the ground level.

Another concern is the issue of over-abstraction of water from the lake, which is one of the reasons behind the lake level declining (Naini Lake – UNDP, 2017). As per a report of Water Resource Group (2015), water security is a challenge even for areas that have a reasonable amount of water but are extensively abstracted to meet the demand. Institutions have implemented short-term demand management responses such as water rationing to regulate the over-abstraction. The management of this abstraction is overseen by three institutions – Jal Sansthan, Irrigation Department and Nainital District Administration, which raises concerns regarding accountability and risk responsibility. As a result, the management of water resources in Nainital remains fragmented, with multiple departments and institutions sharing responsibilities but lacking a coordinated approach.

Impact on environment

The impacts of institutional overlapping on the environment are significant (Dasgupta & Cian, 2016) and particularly relevant in the case of Nainital. Rapid urbanization, unplanned construction activities, and encroachment on the recharge areas have already compromised the habitat and ecology of the city (Jain et al., 2023). In addition, the influx of silt, solid waste, construction debris, and other pollutants is responsible for eutrophication of lake water and is helping in environmental degradation (Tripathi, 2018). While not all institutions may bear direct responsibility for managing environmental risks, it is in the interests of most institutions to ensure that these risks are managed in a manner that safeguards resources and water supply security while minimizing adverse impacts on the environment (Johnson & Handmer, 2002).

This section discusses approaches that can be adapted within a set institutional framework to decrease the vulnerabilities of the hill cities to water issues without compromising environmental sustainability. There are many viable nature-centric water management measures which might be applicable in Nainital and can be easily taken up by any of the concerned institutions and executed at various scales (Table 2). Following are the suggestive interventions that can be adopted at different levels of institutions.

Table 2

Nature-centric approaches for respective institutions.

ApproachProposed respective institutionExample from other hilly areas
Rain water harvesting (RWH) NNPP as a chief municipal body and NLRSDA can intervene at regulating buildings and incorporating RWH provisions into public spaces. Potential of RWH in hilly areas (Khandelwal et al., (2019))
RWH in Kathmandu Valley, Nepal (Shrestha, (2009)
Springshed management Irrigation Department and Forest Department can jointly work and play major roles in the revival and restoration of springs. NGOs, private organizations, and local communities can also play major roles in this program. Implemented by various individual organizations in Eastern and Western Himalayas (Seidler et al., (2016); Gupta & Kulkarni, (2018); Sharma et al., (2020)).
This practice is also successful in some parts of Nepal (Shrestha et al., (2017)). 
Reuse of wastewater Irrigation Department of Nainital has some future plan to use this untapped resource of water with the technical and financial support of other concerned institutions. In Kathmandu valley (Nepal), less than 50% of the total generated wastewater is collected and treated (Christopher et al., (2019)).
Role of waste water treatment plant in mountain areas (Maunoir et al., (2007)
Traditional water management practices The Forest Department, in collaboration with local NGOs and community leaders, leverages its expertise in natural resource management to implement appropriate traditional water management techniques. Traditional water management techniques are practiced in Western (Himachal Pradesh) and Eastern (Meghalaya and Nagaland) Himalayas (Saika, (2014)).
Traditional water harvesting systems in Uttarakhand (Joshi, (2018)
Capacity building To secure the participation of local community, informal institutions should come forward and take the lead. In addition, the capacities of the concerned departments involved in water management should be strengthened so that their ability to manage water in a sustainable manner also increases. Capacity development is necessary for improved water management (a report by UNESCO-IHE, (2009)). 
ApproachProposed respective institutionExample from other hilly areas
Rain water harvesting (RWH) NNPP as a chief municipal body and NLRSDA can intervene at regulating buildings and incorporating RWH provisions into public spaces. Potential of RWH in hilly areas (Khandelwal et al., (2019))
RWH in Kathmandu Valley, Nepal (Shrestha, (2009)
Springshed management Irrigation Department and Forest Department can jointly work and play major roles in the revival and restoration of springs. NGOs, private organizations, and local communities can also play major roles in this program. Implemented by various individual organizations in Eastern and Western Himalayas (Seidler et al., (2016); Gupta & Kulkarni, (2018); Sharma et al., (2020)).
This practice is also successful in some parts of Nepal (Shrestha et al., (2017)). 
Reuse of wastewater Irrigation Department of Nainital has some future plan to use this untapped resource of water with the technical and financial support of other concerned institutions. In Kathmandu valley (Nepal), less than 50% of the total generated wastewater is collected and treated (Christopher et al., (2019)).
Role of waste water treatment plant in mountain areas (Maunoir et al., (2007)
Traditional water management practices The Forest Department, in collaboration with local NGOs and community leaders, leverages its expertise in natural resource management to implement appropriate traditional water management techniques. Traditional water management techniques are practiced in Western (Himachal Pradesh) and Eastern (Meghalaya and Nagaland) Himalayas (Saika, (2014)).
Traditional water harvesting systems in Uttarakhand (Joshi, (2018)
Capacity building To secure the participation of local community, informal institutions should come forward and take the lead. In addition, the capacities of the concerned departments involved in water management should be strengthened so that their ability to manage water in a sustainable manner also increases. Capacity development is necessary for improved water management (a report by UNESCO-IHE, (2009)). 

Rainwater harvesting

This has great potential to address some of today's water crises in many of the hill areas. As per the report ‘Water storage – A strategy for climate change adaptation in Himalayas’ published by ICIMOD (2009), in the Himalayan region, most of the rain and snow generally falls during a short period. Thus, to make water available for human use, the water must be collected or ‘harvested’ when rain or runoff is available. Harvesting storm water minimizes the use of municipal treated water for non-potable use (Che-Ani et al., 2009), and in the case of Nainital, it will also help to maintain the lake level.

Springshed management

Most of the urban Himalayan cities are heavily dependent on spring sources for their water supply and drinking (Bharti et al., 2019). We can replicate this idea in Nainital, as in previous times, springs were the main source of water for the city, but at present according to Jal Sansthan Uttarakhand, merely 0.67 mld water is coming from the springs.

Wastewater treatment

As Nainital does not have sewage treatment facilities, a conceptual water management strategy based on the use of non-conventional water resources can be used. Its applicability should be promoted while recognizing that it requires a distinct change in the behavioural patterns of institutions, utilities, and individuals.

Traditional water systems

Despite their proven benefits for the environment and the communities they serve, traditional water systems are consistently overlooked in government strategies. Reviving traditional water sources holds utmost significance in the sustainable conservation of water resources within the Himalayan region (Sharma et al., 2020).

Capacity building

There should be initiatives stressing the involvement of communities. Overlooking of community governance can be a failure for institutions working on water sector development (Shunglu et al., 2022).

According to Gain et al., 2016, water plays a central role in sustainable development and presents a significant global challenge. However, with efficient and equitable management, water can serve as a key facilitator in enhancing the resilience of social, economic, and environmental systems. Evaluating the existing water institutional framework and policies is crucial in addressing the water crisis (Saleth & Dinar, 2006; De Stefano et al., 2014). Bandyopadhyay (2016) emphasizes the need for a new interdisciplinary institutional framework to enhance water security, focusing on state-level consolidation and the empowerment of local governments, as water is a state subject in India. Singh & Pandey (2020) also suggested the development or reassessment of groundwater abstraction policies, especially in mountainous regions facing increasing population pressure.

There are policies and institutions in place for conserving and protecting water resources, as well as regulating groundwater extraction and construction in areas surrounding rivers and lakes that serve urban populations, but these policies are seldom followed, and institutions require strengthening (Singh & Gopal, 2002). The implemented policies in Nainital often prioritize the development of water resources over their sustainable management, highlighting the urgent need to consider the entire ecosystem, which faces growing threats due to heightened pressure on water resources. The current institutional framework of the city is ineffective in reconciling stakeholders' diverse needs, leading to inadequate coordination and the inability to ensure a fair water supply. Improving the institutional framework can help find sustainable solutions to water management problems. Western Himalayan town Dharamshala (Himachal Pradesh, India) serves a positive example of effective resource management by the administration, which has ensured that the town will not face water issues in the future (Thakur, 2018).

The study underscores the importance of improving the institutional capacity of Nainital to understand threats to water resources and the environment. It emphasizes the need to achieve a balance between water availability, demand, and security by prioritizing effective water governance. Research also advocates the integration of nature-centric approaches into institutional framework for sustainable water management.

One notable limitation was the under-representation of females and elderly people in our sample population. This disparity raises concerns as the perspectives and needs of female residents may differ significantly from those of their male counterparts. Future research endeavours should prioritize efforts to enhance the inclusivity of survey participation to ensure a more representative and robust analysis of the challenges and priorities related to water supply in the city.

The study was conducted under the project ‘Hydrogeological Assessment and Socio-Economic Implications of Depleting Water Resources in tourist towns of Uttarakhand’. The authors are obliged to all stakeholders for sharing the information and helping in the making of this manuscript. Authors also want to thank Mr Laraib Ahmad, Ph.D scholar, IIRS, Dehradun for giving his contribution in map making.

This work was financially supported by the Ministry of Jal Shakti, Department of Water Resources (MOWR), River Development (RD) and Ganga Rejuvenation (GR), Government of India under the Action Research category of R&D activity.

The study was carried out in a responsible manner and research involving human participants was conducted ethically and in compliance with relevant regulations. Researchers provided comprehensive information about the research including its purpose and procedure to the participants and interviewed the participants only after verbal consent and willingness to participate. The approval from an independent ethics committee (Research Ethics Committee – Centre for Ecology Development and Research) was waived in the manuscript because prior consent from each participant was taken through phone calls and appointment.

The authors affirm that they have no competing interests or conflicts of interest to disclose regarding the subject matter or materials discussed in this paper.

Data cannot be made publicly available; readers should contact the corresponding author for details.

The authors declare there is no conflict.

Akhmouch
A.
&
Correia
F. N.
(
2016
).
The 12 OECD principles on water governance—When science meets policy
.
Utilities Policy
43
,
14
20
.
Bandyopadhyay
J.
(
2016
).
New institutional structure for water security in India. 51.15-17. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/301657982_New_institutional_.
Bharti
N.
,
Khandekar
N.
,
Sengupta
P.
,
Bhadwal
S.
&
Kochhar
I.
(
2019
).
Dynamics of urban water supply management of two Himalayan towns in India
.
Water Policy
22
(
S1
),
65
89
.
Charles
S. S.
,
Mwaruvanda
W.
&
Van Koppen
B.
(
2005
).
Integrated water resource management in Tanzania: Interface between formal and informal institutions
. In:
International Workshop on ‘African Water Laws: Plural Legislative Frameworks for Rural Water Management in Africa’
,
26–28 January
,
Johannesburg, South Africa
.
Chauhan
D.
,
Muthuprasad
T.
,
Pandey
A.
,
Singh
N.
,
Singh
V.
,
Sen
S.
&
Rajiv
P.
(
2021
).
Climate Change Water Vulnerability and Adaptation Mechanism in Constrained Touristic Himalayan City, Nainital
.
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-571054/v1
.
Che-Ani
A. I.
,
Shari
N.
,
Sairi
A.
,
Zain
M. F. M.
&
Tahir
M. M.
(
2009
).
Rainwater harvesting as an alternative water supply in the future
.
European Journal of Scientific Research
34
,
32
140
.
Chhimwal
M.
,
Kaur
S.
,
Srivastava
R. K.
,
Hagare
D.
&
Shivprasad
H. J.
(
2022
).
Water quality of springs and lakes in the Kumaon Lesser Himalayan Region of Uttarakhand, India
.
Journal of Water and Health
20
(
4
),
737
754
.
Christopher
A. S.
,
Zhang
F.
,
Mukherji
A.
,
Immerzeel
W.
,
Mustafa
D.
&
Bharati
L.
(
2019
).
The Hindu Kush Himalaya Assessment
.
Dame
J.
,
Schmidt
S.
,
Muller
J.
&
Nusser
M.
(
2019
).
Urbanisation and socio-ecological challenges in high mountain towns: Insights from Leh (Ladakh), India
.
Landscape and Urban Planning
189
,
189
199
.
Dasgupta
S.
&
Cian
E. D.
(
2016
).
Institutions and Environment: Existing Evidence and Future Directions
.
Dash
R. R.
,
Mehrotra
I.
,
Kumar
P.
&
Grischek
T.
(
2008
).
Lake bank filtration at Nainital, India: Water-quality evaluation
.
Hydrogeology Journal
16
,
1089
1099
.
De Stefano
L.
,
Svendsen
M.
,
Giordano
M.
,
Steel
B. S.
,
Brown
B.
&
Wolf
A. T.
(
2014
).
Water governance benchmarking: Concepts and approach framework as applied to Middle East and North Africa countries
.
Water Policy
16
(
6
),
1121
1139
.
Divyanjali
T.
,
Priyanka
G.
,
Singh
R.
,
Gahlot
A.
,
Twala
B.
,
Priyadarshi
N.
&
Akram
S
. (
2023
).
Assessment of environmental degradation of lakes of Nainital district: An ecohydrological perspective
.
SN Applied Sciences
5
,
271
.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s42452-023-05491-9
.
D'Souza
R.
(
2001
).
International law recolonizing the third world? Law and conflicts over water in the Krishna river basin
. In
Law History and Colonialism
(Colborne, D., ed.).
Manchester University Press
,
Manchester
.
Environmental and Social Systems Assessment
(
2017
).
Uttarakhand Water Supply and Sanitation Program for Peri-Urban Areas. Available from: https://swajal.uk.gov.in/upload/announcements/Announcement-5.pdf
.
Gain
A. K.
,
Giupponi
C.
&
Wada
Y.
(
2016
).
Measuring global water security towards sustainable development goals
.
Environmental Research Letters
11
,
124015
.
Global Water Partnership
(
2009
).
Capacity development is necessary for improved water management – UNESCO IHE. Available from: https://www.gwp.org/globalassets/global/toolbox/references/capacity-development-for-improved-water-management-unesco-iheunw-dpc-2009.pdf.
Gupta
A.
&
Kulkarni
H.
(
2018
).
Report of Working Group I Inventory and Revival of Springs in the Himalayas for Water Security. NITI Aayog, 4
.
ICIMOD
(
2009
).
Water storage - A strategy for climate change adaptation in Himalayas. No. 56 Winter edition, ICIMOD Publication, Kathmandu, Nepal
. .
Jain
P.
,
Singh
I.
&
Jain
M.
(
2023
).
Built-up analysis of the Hill Town of Nainital
.
Journal of Surveys in Fisheries Sciences
10
(
2S
),
3872
3878
.
Johnson
C.
&
Handmer
J.
(
2002
).
Water supply in England and Wales: Whose responsibility is it when things go wrong?
Water Policy
4
(
4
),
345
366
.
doi:10.1016/S1366-7017(02)00034
.
Joshi
N. C.
(
2018
).
Saving Traditional Water Harvesting Systems in Uttarakhand
. .
Khandelwal
P.
,
Kumar
S.
&
Sharma
K.
(
2019
).
Rainwater harvesting in Hilly areas
.
International Journal for Technological Research In Engineering
6
(
9
),
5419
5423
.
Maunoir
S.
,
Philip
H.
&
Rambaud
A.
(
2007
).
Small wastewater treatment plants in mountain areas: Combination of septic tank and biological filter
.
Water Science and Technology
56
(
10
),
65
71
.
Mondal
T. K.
&
Roychowdhury
P.
(
2019
).
Water scarcity in Himalayan hill town: A study of Darjeeling Municipality, India
. In:
Urban Drought. Disaster Risk Reduction (Methods, Approaches and Practices)
.
Ray
B.
&
Shaw
R.
, (eds).
Springer
,
Singapore
, pp.
363
383
.
Narain
V.
(
2000
).
India's water crisis: The challenges of governance
.
Water Policy
2
,
433
444
.
Nleya
N.
(
2005
).
Institutional overlaps in water management in the Eerste River catchment
.
Environmental Science, Geography, Sociology
.
Ojha
H.
,
Kovacs
E.
,
Devkota
K.
,
Neupane
K. R.
,
Dahal
N.
&
Vira
B.
(
2019
).
Local experts as the champions of water security in the Nepalese town of Dhulikhel
.
New Angle: Nepal Journal of Social Science and Public Policy
5
(
1
),
1
14
.
Ojha
H.
,
Neupane
K. R.
,
Pandey
C. L.
,
Singh
V.
,
Bajracharya
R.
&
Dahal
N.
(
2020
).
Scarcity amidst plenty: Lower Himalayan cities struggling for water security
.
Water
12
,
567
.
https://doi.org/10.3390/w12020567
.
Ostrom
E.
(
1990
).
Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action
.
Cambridge University Press
,
Cambridge, England
.
Paavola
J.
(
2007
).
Institutions and environmental governance: A reconceptualization
.
Ecological Economics
63
(
1
),
93
103
.
Pahl-Wostl
C.
,
Lebel
L.
,
Knieper
C.
&
Nikitina
E.
(
2012
).
From applying panaceas to mastering complexity: Toward adaptive water governance in river basins
.
Environmental Science & Policy
23
,
24
34
.
Pandey
C.
,
Maskey
G.
,
Devkota
K.
&
Ojha
H.
(
2019
).
Investigating the institutional landscape for urban water security in Nepal
.
Sustainability
12
(
3
),
173
181
.
https://doi.org/10.1089/sus.2019.0007
.
Purushothaman
P.
,
Mishra
S.
,
Das
A.
&
Chakrapani
G. J.
(
2012
).
Sediment and hydro biogeochemistry of Lake Nainital, Kumaun Himalaya, India
.
Environmental Earth Sciences
65
(
3
),
775
788
.
Raghav
P.
(
2020
).
Impact of Urbanisation on Water Resources & Opportunity of RWH Structure in Nainital
.
TERI, School of Advance Studies
,
Delhi
.
ResearchGater
(
2017
).
A Report on Naini Lake, UNDP
(
2017
). .
Saika
A.
(
2014
).
Traditional Systems of Water Management in India
. .
Saleth
R. M.
(
2004
).
Strategic Analysis of Water Institutions in India: Application of A new Research Paradigm. Research report 79. IWMI, Colombo, Sri Lanka
.
Saleth
R. M.
(
2018
).
Editorial: The institutional economics of water
.
Water Economics and Policy
4
(
03
),
1802003
.
Saleth
R. M.
&
Dinar
A.
(
1999
).
Water Challenge and Institutional Response: A Cross Country Perspective
.
World Bank
,
Washington, DC
.
Saleth
R. M.
&
Dinar
A.
(
2004
).
The Institutional Economics of Water: A Cross-Country Analysis of Institutions and Performance
.
Edward Elgar Publishing
,
Cheltenham, UK
.
Saleth
R. M.
&
Dinar
A.
(
2006
).
Water institutional reforms in developing countries: Insights, evidences, and case studies
. In:
Economic Development and Environmental Sustainability: New Policy Options
.
Lopez
R.
&
Toman
M. A.
, (eds).
Oxford University Press
,
Oxford, UK
, pp.
273
306
.
Saleth
R. M.
&
Dinar
A.
(
2008
).
Quantifying Institutional Impacts and Development Synergies in Water Resource Programs: A Methodology With Application to the Kala Oya Basin, Sri Lanka
.
The World Bank
,
Washington, DC
.
Santoshi
N.
&
Roy
S.
(
2019
).
Water Shortage Worsens as Tourist Influx Peaks in Uttarakhand
. .
Seidler
R.
,
Sharma
G.
&
Telwala
Y.
(
2016
).
Climate vulnerability, water vulnerability: challenges to adaptation in eastern Himalayan Springsheds
.
Dev Earth Surf Process
21
,
279
308
.
Sengupta
S.
,
Kukreti
I.
&
Narain
S.
(
2017
).
Naini Lake is depleting but can we undo the wrongs?
Down to Earth
.
Shah
M.
&
Kulkarni
H.
(
2015
).
Urban water systems in India
.
Economic and Political Weekly
50
(
30
),
57
69
.
Shrestha
R. R.
(
2009
).
Rainwater harvesting and ground water recharge for storage in the Kathmandu valley, Water Storage: A Strategy for Climate Change Adoption in the Himalayas, ICIMOD, Kathmandu, Nepal, No.56, pages 27-30. Available from: www. books.icimod.org.
Shrestha
R.
,
Desai
J.
,
Mukherji
A.
,
Dhakal
M.
,
Kulkarni
H.
&
Acharya
S.
(
2017
).
Application of Eight-step Methodology for Reviving Springs and Improving Springshed Management in the Mid-hills of Nepal. ICIMOD. Available from: https://lib.icimod.org/record/32564/files/icimodWLE017.pdf.
Shrestha
K.
,
Singh
S.
&
Prakash
A.
(
2020
).
What lies behind the deepening water crisis in Himalayan towns? Citizen Matters. Available from: https://citizenmatters.in/urbanisation-water-m.
Shunglu
R.
,
Kopke
S.
,
Kanoi
L.
,
Nissanka
T. S.
,
Withanachchi
C. R.
,
Gamage
D. U.
,
Dissanayake
H. R.
,
Kibaroglu
A.
,
Unver
O.
&
Withanachchi
S. S.
(
2022
).
Barriers in participative water governance: A critical analysis of community development approaches
.
Water
14
,
762
.
https://doi.org/10.3390/w14050762
.
Singh
K.
(
2017
).
To Revive Naini Lake, CM Gives Maintenance to Irrigation Department
. .
Singh
N.
(
2021
).
Nainital water woes: Every drop of rain counts. India water portal. Available from: https://www.indiawaterportal.org/articles/nainitals-water-woes-every-drop-rain-counts
.
Singh
S. P.
&
Gopal
B.
(
2002
).
Integrated Management of Water Resources of Lake Nainital and its Watershed: An Environmental Economics Approach
.
Singh
S.
,
Hassan
S. T. M.
,
Hassan
M.
&
Bharti
N.
(
2019
).
Urbanisation and water insecurity in The Hindu Kush Himalaya: Insights from Bangladesh, India, Nepal and Pakistan
.
Water Policy
22
(
S1
),
9
32
.
https://doi.org/10.2166/wp.2019.215
.
Thakur
N. K.
(
2018
).
Shimla Water Crisis: Dharamshala Shows Way to Harness Water Resources
. .
Thompson
H.
,
Stimie
C. M.
,
Richter
E.
&
Perret
S.
(
2001
).
Policies, Legislation and Organizations related to Water in South Africa, with Special Reference to the Olifants River Basin. International Water Management Institute working Paper 18, South African Working paper no7. Available from: http://www.iwmi.cgiar.org/pubs/working/WOR18.pdf.
Tripathi
M.
(
2018
).
Land-use transformation: Challenging carrying capacity and decaying quality of life in Nainital Lake Catchment area
.
International Journal of Applied Social Science
5
(
12
),
2451
2461
.
UIRUDP
(
2021
).
A Report – Initial Environment Examination
.
UNDP-SIWI
.
Water Governance Facility. Available from
: https://siwi.org/undp-siwi-water-governance-facility/what-is-water-governance/the-challenge
UNESCO
(
2016
).
The United Nations World Water Development Report – Water and Jobs. Available from: https://www.unesco.org/en/wwap/wwdr/2016.
Urban Development Department
(
2007
).
City Development Plan: Nainital. Available from: https://udd.uk.gov.in/files/CDP_NITL.PDF.
UUSDA
(
2020
).
Detailed Project Report on Nainital Sewerage System Improvement
.
Uttarakhand
.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Licence (CC BY 4.0), which permits copying, adaptation and redistribution, provided the original work is properly cited (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).