Water transparency is an important ecological indicator for shallow lakes. The largest shallow lake, Poyang Lake, as well as the most typical river-connected lake in China was selected as the research area. In view of the complicated water-sediment conditions induced by its frequent water exchange with external rivers, the dominant factors driving water transparency were determined against the field investigated data from 2003 to 2013 and a specific driving function was established. A numerical model coupling suspended sediment, Chl-a and chemical oxygen demand was developed and validated, and the spatial water transparency distributions under three typical current structures in Poyang Lake, Gravity-style, Jacking-style and Backflow-style, were quantitatively estimated. The following results stood out: water transparency in the lake varied distinctly with the current status; Backflow-style current was basically characterized by the lowest water transparency, while that under Jacking-style was the highest due to the lower sediment carrying capacity. In some outlying regions in the lake, where the water current is hardly influenced by the mainstream, the water transparency was always kept at a stable level.
Water transparency is the distance from water surface to the invisible–visible position of a Secchi Disc, which not only describes the turbidity degree but also indicates the eutrophication level (Zhang et al. 2003; Naumenko 2007). Water transparency contributes to maintain the health and stabilization of water environment, as well as the aquatic ecosystem (Gordon & Brown 1972). Nevertheless, due to the intensive soil erosion, enhanced anthropogenic pollutant and accelerating water eutrophication, a decreasing trend of water transparency is observed in many lakes in recent years (Zhang et al. 2003; Li 2006). The reduced water transparency can affect the photosynthesis process of floating and submerged plants, change the community structure of aquatic animals, and harm the ecological balance by weakening the underwater light intensity. Water transparency is closely related to a combination of a series of environmental factors including optical attenuation, water physicochemical properties and water body compositions such as suspended particles, phytoplankton, and dissolved organic matters (Kirk 1994; Li 2006).
Given the different environmental characters in different lakes and the varied dominant factors involved in transparency fluctuation, it is hard to conduct a quantitative study to investigate the driving mechanisms of water transparency. So far, the concern on water transparency has not got broad attention. Since the late 1970s, several researchers have carried out some related works (Jonasz & Prandke 1986; Hall & Rao 1997), which provided useful information to learn the changing principles of transparency. However, most of them were traditionally performed by simple analyzing and there are still two points that have been less focused. First, the present results were generally conducted based on limited field data and suffered from not explicitly establishing a driving function for water transparency. Due to the coarse sampling frequencies and limited sampling points, it is difficult to comprehend the temporal and spatial transparency distribution for an entire water body, which are usually featured by environmental characters that are uneven in both time and space scales. Moreover, most of these studies basically aimed at isolated lakes, of which the environment characters were relatively stable, and few attention has been paid to river-connected lakes. Compared to an isolate lake, lakes of this kind are always characterized by more complicated environmental features due to the frequent water volume and material exchange with the external rivers, such as the uneven distributed water current, wide water level fluctuation, short water age and high suspended sediment (SS) concentration (Yuan et al. 2011; Wang et al. 2014). These factors always result in a high frequency of ecological properties in river-connected lakes and make more uneven the distribution of water transparency in time and space scales. A quantitative insight into the driving mechanism of water transparency in this kind of lakes can merit the effective use of the lake landscape function, promote the restoration of aquatic community structure, and contribute to keeping the lake ecological balance.
Here, Poyang Lake, the largest freshwater lake as well as the most typical river-connected lake in China, was selected as the research area. The lake is one of the most important ecological regions recognized by the Global Natural Fund and is the important habitat for the endangered Siberian crane as more than 95% of its world population congregates here during the winter (Han et al. 2015; You et al. 2015). However, the water transparency decrease in recent years is accelerating the aquatic ecosystem degradation in Poyang Lake, and is correspondingly threatening the habitat conditions in dry seasons. The objectives of this work were to (1) explore the relationships between water transparency and different environmental factors such as SS, Chl-a and chemical oxygen demand (COD), based on the field monitored data and extract a specific driving function for water transparency in Poyang Lake, (2) develop and validate a numerical model that can yield realistic and accurate simulations of water transparency in Poyang Lake, and (3) simultaneously show water transparency distribution covering the whole lake under different flow structures, which are induced by the uneven water exchange between Poyang Lake and the external rivers. This study may provide references for policy makers who are attempting to prevent ecological degradation and improve the water quality of river-connected lakes.
METHODS AND MATERIALS
The materials dominating underwater light intensity and spectral distribution in shallow lakes can be classified to the following three items (Bricaud et al. 1981; Kirk 1994): (1) suspended substance, mainly composed of inorganic suspended particles and organic detritus produced by death phytoplankton; (2) phytoplankton, including different types of planktonic algae; (3) chromophoric dissolved organic matter (CDOM), made up of humic acid and aromatic polymer (Brezonik & Arnold 2011; Patrick et al. 2014). Due to the frequent water exchange between Poyang Lake and the external rivers, the suspended substance in Poyang Lake is mainly featured by SS. CDOM is a kind of inert material in water body, which is always conservative, especially in marine circumstances. However, in inland lakes, as a result of the relatively higher suspended material content, CDOM usually cannot play an evident role in light attenuation. In view of the complicated chemical composition of CDOM and the high difficulties in extraction and determination, in the present work, we determined COD index for evaluation instead (Su et al. 2001). Besides the above three main factors, water transparency can also be indirectly affected by some other environmental characters such as pH, total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP). For example, under the situation of high pH value, phosphate will be easily transformed to insoluble tricalcium phosphate and Fe3+ will be simply formed to Fe (OH) 3 suspending in the water body. High concentration of TN and TP can accelerate algae proliferation, which may to some extent generate a decrease in water transparency.
Water transparency is a status index influenced by the combination of several characters. The numerical description for these factors is an important foundation for water transparency simulation. Given the complicated hydrodynamic conditions in Poyang Lake, a 2-D unsteady model coupling water flow, water quality, SS and algae growth was developed for water transparency simulations.
SSs transport model
Algae growth model
Model numerical solution
The equations were solved by the finite volume method on an unstructured grid and the flux vector splitting scheme was used to calculate the normal fluxes of the variables across the interfaces between elements. Detailed calculation steps were documented in the references (Hu & Tan 1995; Ding et al. 2006).
Field relationships between water transparency and environmental factors
Water transparency driving function
|.||SD .||SS .||COD .||Chl-a .||TN .||TP .||pH .|
|.||SD .||SS .||COD .||Chl-a .||TN .||TP .||pH .|
aIndicates significance level of 1%.
bIndicates significance level of 5%.
Model calibration and verification
(1) Under gravity-style current, the average water transparency in the south lake was about 61.3 cm, but in the inlet area of Fu River south branch the transparency was observed at lower level of 18.5 cm for high SS concentration. The middle of the southernmost lake was characterized by the best water transparency of 72 cm to 75 cm because it is located in the coccygeal end region of the lake and the water disturbance was notably reduced. The same case was detected in the area located to the north of Xiu River, where the transparency could reach 71.5 cm. Since the Gan River south branch, Fu River west branch and Xin River were integrated in the joint area of south lake and middle lake, water transparency here was lower than that in other districts of the south lake, for the strong water current enhanced sediment suspension, of which the average level was 42.5 cm. For the expanded flow section in the middle lake, the weakened water current cut down the water sediment carrying capacity and strengthened the deposition processes, which played an accelerating role in transparency improvement. But the step-down water velocity also contributed to algae growth reducing the water transparency. The average level ranged from 63 cm to 68 cm. The north lake, where the flow section was narrow and the current intensity was apparently increased, was directly connected to the Yangtze River and the water transparency was approximately 59.5 cm. In the joint area of the north and middle lake, the transparency was evidently reduced to 40.3 cm because the flow section was changed here and the stable current from the middle lake was intensified rapidly, which resulted in a high volume of SS.
(2) In terms of the Jacking-style current, the north lake and the Yangtze River were basically characterized with the same water level. Due to the reduced water disturbance, the water transparency was improved generally than that under the Gravity-style. For example, water transparency in the south lake was increased to 65.8 cm, increased by 7.35% than that under Gravity-style. The most distinct transparency improvement was observed in the joint area of the south lake and middle lake with the average value rising by 54.1% to 65.5 cm. Since water in the middle lake could not be easily transported out to the Yangtze River, the sediment deposition process was enhanced and the water transparency went up between 65 cm and 72 cm. Due to the jacking impacts, an obvious dividing line could be detected in the middle lake. The transparency in the north area of the line was about 3 to 5 cm less than that in the south. The reasons for this might be generalized to the following two points: firstly, the south of the dividing line was the main lake, where the sediment carrying capacity was reduced and the water environment carrying capacity was adequate, both the lower sediment concentration and better water quality contribute to transparency improvement. Secondly, directly connected to the Yangtze River, the north lake was to some extent affected by the external water quantity with higher SS concentration, which reduced the water transparency.
(3) Under the situation of backflow-style current, the higher Yangtze River level resulted in a strong back flow from the river to the lake. The water transparency in the north lake was remarkably reduced than that in the former two conditions. Take the inlet areas of Xiu River and Gan River north branch, for example. The transparencies in this region under the flow structures of Gravity-style and Jacking-style were respectively 60.2 cm and 71.5 cm. Nevertheless, due to influence of the water volume from the Yangtze River, the transparency here was evidently reduced to 48.5 cm in the backflow-style situation, separately decreased by 19.4% and 32.2% than that in other two schemes. Water transparency in the south lake under backflow-style current was close to that under Gravity-style, whereas the values in the middle lake was, to an obvious extent, reduced than that under Gravity-style and Jacking-style. In the inlet area of Rao River under the previous two conditions, the water transparencies were respectively 63 cm and 70 cm, but in the Backflow-style current it dropped to 58 cm.
Water transparency in Poyang Lake varied remarkably under different flow conditions. The Backflow-style current structure was characterized by the lowest water transparency, and in the Jacking-style situation the water transparency basically reach the best level. Some regions located in the coccygeal end of the lake were detected with a steady water transparency because the water currents in these area were relatively independent and less influenced by the outer flow.
Unlike an isolated lake, river-connected lakes are always featured with frequently fluctuated environmental characters and more complicated water transparency changing mechanisms. In the present work, we selected Poyang Lake, the largest and most typical river-connected lake in China, to conduct a case study. Based on long-term field investigated data, the relationships between water transparency and some environment factors were analyzed and the dominant items of SS, Chl-a and COD were determined to establish a driving function for water transparency in the Lake. The function was incorporated to develop a coupled model and the most typical three water structures, Gravity-style, Jacking-style, and Backflow-style current, were selected for numerical study. The results showed that the water transparency in Poyang Lake markedly varied with the current status. Water transparency under the Backflow-style current was detected at the lowest level, whereas the Jacking-style was characterized by the best water transparency. Due to the independent flow, the transparency in some coccygeal end area of the lake was basically kept at a stable level. This work will provide an important guidance for water quality protection and ecological restoration in Poyang Lake and, hopefully, encourage large-scale and long-term water transparency research on river-connected lakes. However, there are several uncertainties that may need further exploration. First, at the present work, the driving factors for water transparency were generalized to the three items, SS, Chl-a and COD, but in field conditions, the factors are not limited to this. It would be better to negotiate more water quality parameters, such as temperature, metal ions and the biomass of submerged aquatic plants, to give a more accurate simulation. Furthermore, water transparency is an important ecological index, yet there are some other detailed indices for water quality to represent it as a single index, such as the ‘Effluent Quality Index’ (Rathnayake & Tanyimboh 2012, 2015; Rathnayake 2015). In the future, more efforts should be made to investigate the relationships between these water quality indices, as well as the in-depth driving mechanism for a single index.
This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 51309082), the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (No. 2016B06814), and a project funded by the Priority Academic Program Development of Jiangsu Higher Education Institutions.