To assess the capabilities of the different techniques in predicting Cadmium (Cd) bioavailability in Cd-contaminated soils with the addition of Zn, one in situ technique (diffusive gradients in thin films; DGT) was compared with soil solution concentration and four widely used single-step extraction methods (acetic acid, EDTA, sodium acetate and CaCl2). Wheat and maize were selected as tested species. The results demonstrated that single Cd-polluted soils inhibited the growth of wheat and maize significantly compared with control plants; the shoot and root biomasses of the plants both dropped significantly (P < 0.05). The addition of Zn exhibited a strong antagonism to the physiological toxicity induced by Cd. The Pearson correlation coefficient presented positive correlations (P < 0.01, R > 0.9) between Cd concentrations in two plants and Cd bioavailability indicated by each method in soils. Consequently, the results indicated that the DGT technique could be regarded as a good predictor of Cd bioavailability to plants, comparable to soil solution concentration and the four single-step extraction methods. Because the DGT technique can offer in situ data, it is expected to be widely used in more areas.
Cadmium (Cd) is one of the most toxic heavy metals. Due to Cd's relatively high mobility in soils and highly widespread toxicity to biota at low concentrations, it has been listed in the blacklist of the International Agency for Research on Cancer. The metal is a serious environmental and occupational contaminant and may represent a severe health hazard to humans and animals. Numerous studies have shown that pronounced amounts of Cd were often found to accompany lead (Pb)/zinc (Zn) or other metals in mineralization (Nogueira et al. 2010). Such combined effects may be synergistic, antagonistic, additive, or independent. These combined interactions clearly affect plant growth and other processes (Davison & Zhang 2012).
The ecological effects of heavy metals in soils depend on the metals’ chemical speciation (biological availability), not the total dissolved concentrations. Biological availability refers to the heavy metals that can be taken up by plants. The most impressive ex situ methods for estimating bioavailability of Cd in soils, such as the conventional single and sequential extraction method, soil solution concentration and the isotope dilution exchange method, failed to provide in situ data. However, diffusive gradients in thin films (DGT) is a dynamic and high-resolution technique that could predict Cd bioavailability well in an in situ environment where physical and chemical properties are dynamic (Zhang et al. 1995). DGT is now an established technique that is used for morphological analysis in different fields of research, including water quality monitoring, soils and sediment geochemistry. DGT measures the labile, dissolved fraction of analytes and pre-concentrates them in situ, processes that can reduce the risk of introducing contamination and chemical transformation of the sample. However, the DGT technique perturbs a solution or soil system and imposes the diffusion limiting case, so that metal can rapidly dissociate from solution complexes or from the solid phase while being accumulated by the device. Nolan et al. (2005) found that DGT was a convenient and relatively easy technique to predict metal concentrations in plants. Tandy et al. (2011) as well as Tian et al. (2008) both found that DGT was more accurate than currently available ex situ methods at predicting the bioavailability of heavy metals, specifically plant-available Cu, Zn and P. However, Soriano-Disla et al. (2010) explained that the performance of the DGT method was poor for assessing the transfer of Cd to the root. Almås et al. (2006) confirmed there was no good linear relationship between heavy metals absorbed in plants and the content measured by the DGT technique. Consequently, there is no universal consensus about the reliability of the DGT technique for evaluation of heavy metals bioavailability in soils.
In this study, Cd bioavailability in soils with Zn combined pollution was systemically investigated by comparing the DGT technique with soil solution concentrations and traditional extraction methods (HAc, EDTA, NaAc and CaCl2). Two typical plants (wheat and maize) were examined for Cd uptake. The Pearson correlation coefficient between Cd concentrations in the two plants and the Cd bioavailability was used to confirm the best method for predicting the concentration of labile Cd in Cd-Zn complex contaminated soils.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Soil sample and incubation
Bulk samples of topsoil (0–20 mm) were collected from Jiang Xinzhou vineyard of Nanjing using the diagonal method and were later reduced by quartering. After being mixed evenly, the soil sample was air-dried at room temperature and sieved with a 3-mm stainless steel mesh. The basic chemical properties of the uncontaminated soil samples were pH (6.5), organic matter (2.5%), cation exchange capacity (CEC, 26.9 cmol·kg−1), and total metal concentrations (0.22 mg Cd·kg−1, 130.8 mg Zn·kg−1, 19.04 mg Pb·kg−1 and 64.4 mg Cu·kg−1). Bainong AK58 (wheat) and Zhengdan 958 (maize) were selected as test materials.
Two widely used plant species (wheat, Triticum aestivum; maize, Zea mays) were selected as the test species. Separate subsamples were amended with either Cd stock solutions only or Cd-Zn complex solutions. The added concentrations of Zn were 0, 50, 100, 200, 300, 400, 600 and 700 mg·kg−1. CdCl2·2.5H2O and ZnSO4 were selected as mother liquor, were added to soil solutions and then blended adequately with equal base fertilizers. Base fertilizers included urea, KH2PO4 and K2SO4; whereas ω (total nitrogen), ω (P2O5) and ω (K2O) were 0.15, 0.10, 0.15 g·kg−1, respectively. The soil was turned over every three or four days to ensure exogenous heavy metals and nutrient elements mixed evenly. After six weeks of aging (Alexander 2000), the pot experiment could be processed. Fifteen seeds of wheat and five seeds of maize were sown in pots filled with 0.75 kg of the added soils with different doses of Cd. Each soil sample at a given metal concentration was in triplicate. After germination, the number of plants per pot was reduced to ten seedlings for wheat and three seedlings for maize. All plants were grown without nutrient addition in a greenhouse under the natural day-night cycle. During the process of plant growth, deionized water was added to maintain 60 percent of the soil moisture every day. After 35 days of growth, all plants were harvested and separated into shoots and roots. The roots of the plants were rinsed with deionized water before they were placed in a solution of 20 mmol·L−1 EDTA for 15 min to remove the heavy metals that were adsorbed onto the root surface. Afterwards, the roots were washed with deionized water again and put into numbered envelopes. The shoots and roots of the plants were dried in an oven at 105°C for 20 minutes de-enzyming. The temperature was reduced to 70°C until the weight was constant. The dry sample weights were recorded and prepared to measure Cd bioavailability. After harvest, the remaining soils were air-dried at room temperature and sieved with a 2-mm stainless steel mesh for the following analysis of Cd bioavailability and total Cd in soils.
Analytical methods of the bioavailable Cd in soils
The DGT procedure was divided into four steps, as follows:
Soil pre-equilibrium. Prior to DGT deployment, the maximum water holding capacity (MWHC) of each soil subsample was measured. Soil samples of 80 g were placed into a plastic pot with 40% MWHC and maintained for 48 h, followed by 80% MWHC for 24 h.
DGT measurements. The appropriate amount of soil sample was put into each plastic cap (8-mm diameter). The assembled DGT devices were deployed on the soil paste of each plastic pot with gentle pressure to ensure complete contact between DGT and the soil paste. Three replicates per soil were used. The petri plate was upended to maintain water-holding capacity. The temperature was maintained exactly.
DGT retrieval and elution. The devices were deployed for 24 h. On retrieval, the devices were jet-washed with deionized water to remove the adhered soil particles before they were disassembled. The resin gels were removed and immersed in 1 mL of 1 mol·L−1 HNO3 for at least 16 h prior to analysis after appropriate dilution.
- DGT calculation. The mass of accumulated Cd (M) in the binding gel was calculated according to formula (1) when it was eluted using a known volume of eluting solution (Ve).Zhang et al. 2002; Luo et al. 2013). The concentrations of Cd measured by DGT (CDGT) were calculated using formula (2):Scally et al. 2006).
Soil solution concentration
The soil solutions were collected by centrifuging the paste soils. After retrieval of the DGT deployments, soils were transferred into 50 mL PTFE tubes and then centrifuged at 4,000 r·min−1 for 20 min. The resulting supernatants were filtered through a 0.45-μm pore size cellulose nitrate filter membrane and then acidified using HNO3. The measured concentration of Cd was recorded as Csol.
Single extraction methods
Acetic acid (HAc) (Luo et al. 2012), EDTA (Feng et al. 2005), sodium acetate (NaAc) (Kaplan et al. 2009) and CaCl2 (Qasim et al. 2015) extractions were selected to extract the bioavailable factions of Cd in this study. The original air-dried rhizosphere soils were used as subsamples for the chemical extractions.
HAc: 0.5 g of soil was extracted with 20 mL of 0.11 mol·L−1 HAc in a 50-mL centrifuge tube, and shaken for 16 h (overnight) (Luo et al. 2012).
EDTA: 2.0 g of soil was extracted with 20 mL of 0.05 mol·L−1 EDTA adjusted using an ammonia solution to pH = 7.0 in a 50-mL centrifuge tube and shaken for 2 h (Feng et al. 2005).
NaAc: 4.0 g of soil was extracted with 20 mL of 1 mol·L−1 NaAc in a 50-mL centrifuge tube and shaken for 2 h (Kaplan et al. 2009).
CaCl2: 2.0 g of soil was extracted with 20 mL of 0.01 mol·L−1 CaCl2 in a 50-mL centrifuge tube and shaken for 2 h (Qasim et al. 2015).
All the extracting solutions were centrifuged at 3,000 r·min−1 for 20 min followed by filtering through a 0.45 μm cellulose nitrate filter membrane. Filtrates were used to measure Cd availability of soil. All of the operations were processed in triplicate at room temperature.
Cd measurements in plants
The shoots and roots of the plants were smashed by pulverizer and sieved through a 2-mm sifter. HNO3-HClO4 was added to the subsamples as a wet digestion reagent. The control test was conducted at the same time. A decomposition reagent was applied to analyze Cd in plants (dry mass was used for calculations).
A graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrophotometer (A3AFC-12, Beijing Purkinje General Instrument Co., Ltd) was used to determine Cd of solution samples. The lowest detectable limit is 0.001 μg·L−1. Excel 2007 was used to analyze experimental data and draw charts, and SPSS statistical package (version 10.0 for Windows) was used to evaluate significance analysis and Pearson correlations.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Effects of Cd along or combined with Zn in soils on the biomass and biota accumulation
Wheat and maize that were grown in Cd single-contaminated soils accumulated more Cd compared with those grown in the control groups. Cd could be accumulated obviously by both the shoots and roots of the plants, but the accumulated mass of Cd was mainly distributed in the roots (Figure 3). Jiang et al. (2001) studied Allium sativum and found similar conclusions as this study. The concentration of Cd decreased in both the shoots and roots when Zn was added (Figure 3). Zn in soils also restrained the absorption of Cd by wheat and maize, indicating that Zn has an antagonistic action on Cd absorption. This result is because Zn and Cd have similar configurations of extra-nuclear electron and ionic radii, elements of similar types that are competing for the same transport and storage sites in the cell and which therefore displace each other from reactive enzymatic and receptor proteins. These actions and reactions might explain why the addition of Zn leads to the decreasing absorption of Cd.
DGT measurement and soil solution concentration
Extractable Cd using single extraction methods
Correlation between Cd concentrations in plants and bioavailable concentrations of Cd
The relationship between plant Cd concentrations and Cd concentrations in particular soils has been applied widely to select the most suitable method of assessment for bioavailable heavy metal testing procedures in soils (Muhammad et al. 2012). In general, the results showed that Cd concentrations in plants had extremely significant correlations (P < 0.01) with the extractable concentrations of Cd by all extraction methods, CDGT and Csol. As listed in Table 1, the R-values between Cd uptake in plants and bioavailable concentrations of Cd all presented above 0.9, indicating that each method used in this study could be a useful substitute for determining plant-available Cd, and the DGT technique could be regarded as a robust tool when predicting Cd bioavailability in soils. Good predicting results have also been found previously, using pot experiments for wheat (Nolan et al. 2005).
|Item .||CDGT .||Csol .||ω (Cd)|
|HAc .||EDTA .||NaAc .||CaCl2 .|
|Item .||CDGT .||Csol .||ω (Cd)|
|HAc .||EDTA .||NaAc .||CaCl2 .|
All results are significantly correlated (two tailed).
The conventional single extraction method is a common evaluation method. As a strong chelating reagent, EDTA has been reported to extract both the organically bound metals and the metals occluded in oxides as well as to partly extract secondary clay minerals, and EDTA could overestimate the bioavailability of the target elements. Previous studies have reported that EDTA was an ideal indicator in assessing the bioavailability of Cd (Zhu et al. 2012). HAc can extract organic matter-bound metals. As the weaker two neutral salts, NaAc and CaCl2 are able to extract exchangeable Cd with the desorbing cations easily in soil mineral surfaces. The capacity of CaCl2-extractable metal concentrations to predict plant availability is metal dependent (Nolan et al. 2005). Many studies have also observed good relationships between Cd uptake by plants and CaCl2-extractable concentrations (Qasim et al. 2015), suggesting that CaCl2 might be a useful extractant for determining plant-available Cd. Similarly, it has been shown that extraction with CaCl2 in various concentrations gives a good indication of the bioavailability of different heavy metals. Csol is often used to indicate bioavailability of heavy metals in soils. Generally, the metal compartments in soils are comprised of inorganic complexes, mineral colloids, organic complexes, and the free metal ion, while the solid phase is represented by tightly bound and exchangeable fractions. The soil solution concentration is able to determine not only the heavy metal fractions that could be absorbed by plants (the total dissolved) but also the inertia fractions that could not be used by plants. It is commonly understood that not only metal speciation at equilibrium but also both dynamic chemical interactions and resupply of metal from the soil solid phase determine metal bioavailability. The DGT technique could measure the concentrations of trace metals, including the dissolved fractions in soil solution and those resupplied from the solid phase in situ. This technique could measure inorganic complexes, a proportion of organic complexes and free metal ions, any of which could be assimilated by the roots from the soil system. pH, dissolved organic carbon, CEC, and texture had no influence on the process of metal uptake when the DGT technique was used. This study verified that the DGT technique was a robust tool for predicting Cd bioavailability in soils. Based on its theoretical advantages, the technique could provide more credible monitoring data and it could be widely used in more areas than other ex situ methods. A previous study has reported that the DGT technique was a useful tool for assessing metal bioavailability in clean and contaminated sediments that were being subjected to varying degrees of sediment disturbance (Amato et al. 2016).
The values of CDGT/Csol ranged from 0 to 1. High values represented an increasing ability for applied soil particles to supply heavy metals to soil solutions. The value of CDGT/Csol decreased with the addition of Zn in the soils growing both wheat and maize. The variation of decrease increased as the addition neared 600–700 mg·kg−1 (Table 2), indicating that the ability of soil particles to supply Cd was limited as a result of the Zn addition. This result also revealed the protective effect Zn had over Cd poisoning in Cd-Zn combined exposure in terms of kinetics. However, the ability of soils growing wheat to supply heavy metals was greatly restrained by the addition of Zn, as indicated by the larger decreasing values of wheat than those of maize (Table 2). The apparent effect was an antagonism: Cd content was reduced because of the Zn addition. Zn could hinder soil particles from releasing Cd, which would reduce Cd concentrations in plants as well as soil solution Csol.
|Wheat .||Maize .|
|Wheat .||Maize .|
Consequently, the study showed the effectiveness of the DGT technique and soil solution concentration as well as the four single-step extraction methods (HAc, EDTA, NaAc and CaCl2) for predicting the bioavailability of Cd to wheat and maize in Cd-Zn complex-contaminated soils. Since the DGT technique could provide in situ data, it could be regarded as a more reliable tool than ex situ methods in predicting the presence of heavy metals.
Single Cd-polluted soils inhibited the growth of plants. The shoot and root biomasses all significantly decreased for wheat and maize (P < 0.05). The addition of Zn could decrease Cd bioavailability in Cd-contaminated soils and suppress the absorption of Cd so as to alleviate the physiological toxicity that was facilitated with wheat and maize. As more Zn was added, a greater effect could be observed during the experiment. Positive correlations (P < 0.01, R > 0.9) were presented between Cd concentrations in two plants and Cd bioavailability, indicating that the DGT measurement predicts Cd bioavailability in Cd-Zn contaminated soils well. The results were comparable to traditional ex situ methods, including soil solution concentration and four widely used single-step extraction methods (HAc, EDTA, NaAc and CaCl2). Based on the DGT technique's theoretical advantages, it could be regarded as a more robust tool than those currently available.
We are grateful for the grants for Project supported by National Science Funds for Creative Research Groups of China (No.51421006), Program for Changjiang Scholars and Innovative Research Team in University (No.IRT13061), National Science Fund For Distinguished Young Scholars (No.51225901), the Key Program of National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 41430751), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No.51579073), the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (No.2015B25314) and a Project Funded by the Priority Academic Program Development of Jiangsu Higher Education Institutions (PAPD).