## Abstract

Bisphenol A (BPA) is a known endocrine disrupter and was detected in surface waters. We investigated the mineralization of BPA by electrochemical oxidation. Six different types of electrodes, including the boron-doped diamond (BDD), platinum (Pt), and mixed metal oxide (MMO) electrodes; RuO2–IrO2, RuO2–TiO2, IrO2–Ta2O5, and Pt–IrO2, were compared as the anode material. Total organic carbon (TOC) was analyzed to monitor the mineralization efficiency of BPA. BDD achieved 100% BPA mineralization efficiency in 180 min and at a current density of 125 mA/cm2, whereas the TOC removal efficiency of Pt was 60.9% and the efficiency of MMO electrodes ranged between 48 and 54%. BDD exhibited much lower specific energy consumption, which corresponds to a lower energy cost (USD63.4 /kg TOC). The effect of operational parameters showed that the BDD anode was much more affected by the current density, initial BPA concentration, and electrolyte concentration than the other parameters such as the stirring speed and interelectrode distance.

## HIGHLIGHTS

• BDD, Pt, RuO2–IrO2, RuO2–TiO2, IrO2–Ta2O5, and Pt–IrO2 were compared as the anode material.

• BDD performed better than MMO anodes for the mineralization of BPA.

• BDD anode showed 100% TOC removal efficiency in 180 min.

• Current efficiency of BDD was 2.53 times higher than Pt and 3.7 times than MMOs.

• The specific energy consumption was higher for MMO electrodes.

### Graphical Abstract

Graphical Abstract
Graphical Abstract

## INTRODUCTION

Bisphenol A (BPA) is the precursor compound for the production of epoxy resins and polycarbonates (Prokop et al. 2004). Approximately 70% of the produced BPA is used for polycarbonate production, 25% for epoxy resin production, and 5% for the production of various phenoplast products (Tsai 2006). Global bisphenol production, which was 1 million tons in the 1980s, increased to 2.2 million tons in 2009 and to 5.4 million tons in 2015 (Fiege et al. 2000). This dramatic increase in the production of BPA requires taking preventive measures for its disposal and release to the environment. BPA is highly toxic in water sources and is known to be a teratogenic and endocrine disruptor in invertebrates (Flint et al. 2012). It may cause contamination in water sources as a result of direct discharges from treatment plants and garbage storage facilities (Kang et al. 2007).

So far, a wide range of methods has been applied to remove BPA from water such as adsorption (Ahamad et al. 2019), photocatalytic oxidation (Dhiman et al. 2017; Kumar et al. 2018), sonophotolytic (Fadaei & Mardani 2014), ultrasound (Maruyama et al. 2006), wet oxidation (Mezohegyi et al. 2013), ultraviolet radiation (Neamţu & Frimmel 2006), and ozonation (Oke & Ogundugba 2014) processes. As a conventional treatment method, sodium hypochlorite was shown to be effective at removing BPA with an efficiency of 99% (Bourgin et al. 2013). Despite the satisfactory removal efficiency, the formation of chlorinated by-products is an important concern. Oke & Ogundugba (2014) showed that ozonation can be effectively used for the removal of BPA from contaminated water or industrial wastewater. They achieved an 81% BPA degradation rate at pH 8.25. In 120 min reaction time, the total organic carbon (TOC) removal rate of BPA using 6.67 mg/min O3 was found to be 41% and 51% at pH 8.25 and pH 11, respectively. The drawback of the ozonation process is considered to be high operating and capital investment costs. The adsorption process is a very effective and low-cost option and widely applied in water treatment (Alshehri et al. 2014). However, the low hydrophobicity (log Kow) of BPA may restrict its adsorption capacity. Neamţu & Frimmel (2006) investigated the removal of BPA from aqueous solutions by the UV/H2O2 process. In 90 min treatment time, they achieved BPA removal efficiencies of 45% and 60% with 8.5 and 17 mg/L H2O2 concentrations, respectively. However, due to the recalcitrant structure of BPA and its resistance to biological degradation, more powerful and novel treatment methods are required.

Electrochemical oxidation (EO) has proved its effectiveness in the treatment of a wide range of wastewaters and the degradation of various recalcitrant pollutants (Ding et al. 2012; Gengec & Kobya 2013; Zaouak et al. 2013; Can et al. 2019a; Turan et al. 2020). This process involves two possible mechanisms for the oxidation of pollutants in an aqueous solution: direct and indirect oxidation. In the case of direct oxidation, pollutants are directly oxidized on the anode surface as a result of the electron transfer between the pollutants and electrode. In the latter case, strong oxidants such as hydroxyl radicals (•OHs), HOCl, SO4•− are formed on the anode and react with pollutants in the bulk solution (Panizza & Cerisola 2009; Martínez-Huitle et al. 2015). The formation of such oxidants depends mostly on the electrode material, applied current, and electrolyte solution. Electrode material plays a key role in controlling the oxidant generation rate and type of oxidants (Martínez-Huitle & Ferro 2006). Various electrode materials have been developed and they have been roughly classified into two types: ‘active’ and ‘nonactive’ by Comninellis (1994). Active electrodes interact strongly with •OH, and thus oxidation of organics occurs selectively as the reactions of oxygen evolution proceeds simultaneously. Mixed metal oxide (MMO) electrodes, which are made by forming a thin layer of metal oxides on the substrates such as platinum and titanium, are classified as active anodes (Soni et al. 2017). Nonactive anodes, on the other hand, such as boron-doped diamond (BDD), interact weakly with •OH. In general, the lower the adsorption strength of the •OH on the electrode surface, the higher the oxygen overpotential for a given electrode material (Zaouak et al. 2014; Groenen Serrano 2018).

Numerous types of anodes have been employed in the EO process for the removal of BPA. For instance, Dong et al. (2019) used BDD anodes for the mineralization of BPA in the presence of NaNO2 electrolyte. They obtained 63.7% TOC removal at a current density of 9.04 mA/cm2 in 60 min. In another study (Li et al. 2017), the EO process using BDD anodes with NaCl as the supporting electrolyte was applied for the BPA removal and obtained a TOC removal efficiency of 77.5%. Other studies in the literature have employed BDD anodes in the EO of BPA (Murugananthan et al. 2008; Wu et al. 2016; Dietrich et al. 2017). Regarding the active electrodes, Xue et al. (2011) applied a type of DSA electrode of Ti/SnO2–Sb2O5/PbO2 for the oxidation of BPA in a sulfate electrolyte solution. Wu et al. (2016) compared two nonactive anodes, BDD and SnO2, in the electrooxidation of BPA, and they concluded that both anodes acted highly different because of their different surface characteristics and oxygen evolution potentials. Moreover, other studies have used carbon fiber (Kuramitz et al. 2001) and graphite (Govindaraj et al. 2013) as electrode materials in the EO of BPA. Overall, these studies employed different electrode materials in various electrolyte mediums, which directly affects the type of oxidant species that will be responsible for the oxidation of BPA. There have been two studies that have investigated the effect of anode material in the EO process for the degradation of BPA (Cui et al. 2009; Wu et al. 2016). Cui et al. (2009) compared the performance of four different titanium (Ti)-based electrodes including Ti/BDD, Ti/Sb–SnO2, Ti/RuO2, and Ti/Pt in a 0.1 M Na2SO4 medium. They conducted the cyclic voltammetry and chrono potentiometry on the anodes and elucidated the degradation pathway of BPA. In another study, Wu et al. (2016) compared BDD anode with two different modified SnO2–Sb anodes in the EO of BPA. They studied the effects of pH and electrolyte medium and found that in 0.1 M NaCl, modified SnO2–Sb anodes exhibited better electrocatalytic activity for BPA oxidation than BDD. Despite the wide range of anode materials employed in the EO of BPA, literature lacks a comprehensive study that investigates the performance of prominent electrode materials. The operation cost is a major concern in electrochemical treatment processes and should be considered along with the process performance.

With these concerns, the present study investigated the performances of different anode materials including BDD, Pt (platinum), and MMO electrodes (Ti/RuO2–TiO2, Ti/RuO2–IrO2, Ti/IrO2–Ta2O5, Ti/Pt–IrO2 in the mineralization of BPA by EO process. Electrodes were compared both in terms of BPA mineralization efficiencies and electrical energy consumptions. For this purpose, the performances of the electrodes on TOC removal were investigated at three different current densities. The effect of various operational parameters (current density, mixing rate, interelectrode distance, initial pollutant concentration, electrolyte concentration) on the process was also determined using the most effective electrode. Finally, specific energy consumption (SEC) was determined based on the amount of consumed electrical energy during TOC removal.

## MATERIAL AND METHOD

### Materials

All the chemicals used in the experiments were of analytical quality and obtained from Sigma Aldrich and Merck. Phosphoric acid was used as the supporting electrolyte during anodic oxidation. BDD, Pt, and MMO electrodes were used as the anode and a stainless-steel electrode was used as the cathode. Pt and MMO electrodes are Ti-based electrodes. BDD electrodes were supplied by DiaCCon GmbH Germany. Pt and MMO electrodes were supplied by Baoji Changli Special Metal Co. Ltd, China. A DC power supply (Agilent 6675A model, USA) was used to provide a maximum output of 20 A-120 V. A magnetic stirrer (Heidolph MR 3000D, Germany) was used to mix the solution.

### Experimental apparatus and procedure

Electrooxidation experiments were performed in a Pyrex glass reactor under galvanostatic conditions. A 500-mL sample of BPA solution was put into the reactor for each experiment. Phosphoric acid was added into the solution as an electrolyte to provide conductivity in the solution. To rule out the additional oxidation that may be caused by the anion of a supporting electrolyte (such as Cl2, SO42, etc.), we used phosphoric acid as a weak acid. For the reactor and experimental setup, see our previous paper (Can et al. 2019b). No pH adjustment was made in the experiments, and the test solution was started at the natural pH (pH 2.5). The pH was measured at the end of the study. The change in the pH at the end of the experiment was found to be no more than 0.2. The increase in temperature during the test period was maintained at 38–42 °C by supplying external air to the outer wall of the reactor.

### Analytical method

Mineralization of organic matters is defined as the conversion of them into the final products of CO2 and H2O by the oxidation process. The mineralization rate of the organic matter content of the solution was determined by monitoring the TOC concentration. The TOC content of the solutions was determined by the non-purgeable organic carbon method using a TOC analyzer with a non-dispersive IR source (Shimadzu, TOC-L model, Japan). Equations (1)–(4) used in the study are listed below, which are commonly used in literature and described in previous studies (Comninellis & Pulgarin 1991; Lee et al. 2017; Can et al. 2019b).
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
where n = 72, assuming that the overall mineralization of the BPA into CO2 occurs as in the following reaction:
(5)

## RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

In this section, the most suitable anode electrode was determined by comparing the BPA mineralization performances at various current densities. Then the effect of the operating parameters such as the current density, stirring speed, interelectrode gap, initial BPA concentration, and electrolyte concentration on the TOC removal efficiency by the most suitable electrode was determined. It is known that the applied potential and current directly affect the efficiency of the process and the operating cost (Can 2015). Thus, the SEC value that is based on the amount of electricity consumed for TOC removal was also determined.

### The effects of anode type and current density

To investigate the effect of anode type on the TOC removal by the EO process, six different anodes (BDD, Pt, and four MMO electrodes) were compared at different current densities. Figure 1(a) shows the TOC removal efficiencies of different anodes at the current densities of 25, 75, and 125 mA/cm2 in 360 min treatment time. There were remarkable differences among the BDD, Pt, and MMO electrodes in their effectiveness at anodic mineralization of BPA. The comparison of TOC removal efficiencies indicated that the BDD electrode was able to mineralize significantly more BPA than Pt and MMO electrodes. Even at the lowest current density of 25 mA/cm2, the BDD electrode achieved almost 100% BPA mineralization efficiency. On the other hand, TOC removal efficiencies by MMO electrodes at the end of the 360-min were obtained as 61% (Pt), 54% (RuO2–IrO2), 53% (RuO2–TiO2), 50% (IrO2–Ta2O5), and 49% (Pt–IrO2).

Figure 1

(a) TOC removal efficiencies and (b) SEC values of BDD, Pt, and MMO electrodes at different current densities (experimental conditions: reaction time: 360 min, [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, stirring speed = 500 rpm, interelectrode distance: 15 mm, [H3PO4] = 0.25 M, conductivity 22.1 mS/cm).

Figure 1

(a) TOC removal efficiencies and (b) SEC values of BDD, Pt, and MMO electrodes at different current densities (experimental conditions: reaction time: 360 min, [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, stirring speed = 500 rpm, interelectrode distance: 15 mm, [H3PO4] = 0.25 M, conductivity 22.1 mS/cm).

Figure 1(b) displays the SEC values calculated based on the amount of TOC removed by each anode at the current densities of 50, 75, and 125 mA/cm2. The lowest SEC values were achieved for the BDD electrode in the range between 866 and 7,200 kWh/kg TOC. SEC values of Pt and MMO electrodes, from smallest to largest, occurred in the order of Pt > RuO2–TiO2 > Pt–IrO2 > IrO2–Ta2O > RuO2–IrO2. It is worth noting that the SEC value of the IrO2–Ta2O5 electrode was lower than that of the RuO2–IrO2 electrode, despite its lower TOC removal efficiency. This was due to the different potential difference (V) of the electrodes measured during the experiment with each electrode. As the current applied to the electrooxidation cell increases, the potential (V) between the electrodes increases because the solution conductivity is constant. Since the amount of TOC removed does not increase proportionally to the applied current density, an increase in the SEC was observed with an increase in the applied current.

Due to the inherent characteristics of BDD electrodes, which had the highest removal efficiencies, lower voltage values were obtained compared with the other electrodes. Only the BDD electrode was able to achieve the complete mineralization of BPA. At the current density of 75 mA/cm2, 240 min treatment time was sufficient to obtain 100% TOC removal efficiency for the BDD electrode. At the highest current density (125 mA/cm2), this duration decreased to 180 min. Pt performed relatively better than the MMO electrodes, achieving 39% and 43% TOC removal. In contrast, the MMO electrodes achieved 34% and 35% TOC removal on average under the same conditions.

The degradation capacity of the anodes depends on their capabilities to produce •OHs. BDD electrodes have extraordinary properties such as the wide potential window, high electrochemical stability, and negligible adsorption of organic molecules (Enache et al. 2009). Diamond is an exceptional hard crystalline form of carbon, with sp3 hybridized carbon atoms bonded together. Boron doping into diamond gives BDD electrodes p-type semiconducting characteristics by acting as an electron acceptor because of the electron deficiency in its outer shell. With these properties, the BDD electrode is capable of generating high amounts of •OH radicals and other active intermediates through water oxidation. Since these active species are loosely adsorbed on the surface of BDD, they readily attack and cause oxidative mineralization of organic pollutants (Zhi et al. 2003). In the case of MMO electrodes, coating an oxide layer causes the formation of a deactive region that increases the anode potential and leads to mechanical losses at the interface. This results in a decreased electrical conductivity and efficiency in the degradation of pollutants (Moradi et al. 2020).

Another important factor that determines the efficiency of anodes in the degradation of pollutants is their oxidation potentials. Anode electrodes are divided for simplicity into two classes: active and non-active electrodes (Comninellis 1994). Active anodes, which present low oxygen evolution overpoten­tial, are good electrocatalysts for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) and, consequently, lead to selective oxidation of the organic materials due to chemisorbed •OH. Therefore, the oxidation power of this type of anodes is generally low. On the other hand, non-active anodes are weak electrocatalysts for the OER, and direct EO is supposed to oc­cur at these electrodes. A higher oxidation state is unavailable and the organic species are directly oxidized by a physisorbed •OH. Pt-based, Ru-based oxides, and It-based oxides are considered active anodes with low oxidation potential (RuO2–TiO2 = 1.4–1.7 V, IrO2–Ta2O5 = 1.5–1.8 V, Pt = 1.7–1.9 V). On the other hand, BDD is considered non-active, thus presenting high oxidation potential (SnO2 = 1.9–2.2 V, PbO2 1.8–2.0 V, BDD = 2.2–2.6 V). The production of quasi-free •OH on the surface of BDD has been confirmed by electron spin resonance measurements with spin traps. These explain the lower performance of MMO electrodes compared with the BDD anode, on which the •OH is loosely attached. This electrogenerated •OH on the BDD anode is highly reactive and thus can mineralize the organics with a high-current efficiency (Martínez-Huitle & Andrade 2011).

Table 1 shows the electrolysis parameters during the mineralization of BPA by different anodes. As the current density increased, the TOC removal efficiency, average voltage, and SEC all showed an increase, while a decrease with the anode and mineralization efficiency was observed. The higher production rate of •OH with increasing current density can explain the increase in TOC removal efficiency at higher current densities. During electrooxidation, part of the applied electric energy is transformed into heat. Therefore, when the current density (applied current) is increased, the voltage also increases, and more heat is generated. A significant portion of the energy is converted into heat rather than producing •OH. This conversion reduces the efficiency of the process.

Table 1

Electrolysis parameters during the mineralization of BPA by different anodes (experimental conditions: reaction time: 360 min, [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, stirring speed = 500 rpm, interelectrode distance: 15 mm, [H3PO4] = 0.25 M, conductivity 22.1 mS/cm)

AnodeJTOCremUSECCostηMCE
(mA/cm2)(%)(V)(kWh/kg TOCrem)($/kg TOC)(mg TOC/Ahm2)(%) 25 99.1 8.2 865.9 63.4 2,375.0 10.2 BDD 75 100.0 10.8 3,385.3 247.7 798.6 3.4 125 100.0 13.8 7,200.0 526.92 479.2 2.1 25 39.1 4.2 1,132.8 82.9 937.5 4.0 Pt 75 52.2 8.3 4,978.8 364.4 416.7 1.8 125 60.9 12.3 10,515.4 769.5 291.7 1.3 25 27.0 3.8 1,488.8 108.95 645.8 2.8 Ti/Pt–IrO2 75 40.9 8.0 6,144.5 449.7 326.4 1.4 125 48.7 11.5 12,362.1 904.7 233.3 1.0 25 29.6 3.7 1,317.2 96.4 708.3 3.0 Ti/RuO2–TiO2 75 44.3 7.6 5,352.0 391.7 354.2 1.5 125 53.0 11.4 11,163.9 817.0 254.2 1.1 25 26.1 4.3 1,734.4 126.9 625.0 2.7 Ti/RuO2–IrO2 75 44.3 8.8 6,228.7 455.8 354.2 1.5 125 53.9 11.8 11,388.4 833.4 258.3 1.1 25 25.2 4.0 1,637.8 119.8 604.2 2.6 Ti/IrO2–Ta2O5 75 40.0 7.5 5,874.3 429.9 319.4 1.4 125 49.6 11.3 11,915.8 872.03 237.5 1.0 AnodeJTOCremUSECCostηMCE (mA/cm2)(%)(V)(kWh/kg TOCrem)($/kg TOC)(mg TOC/Ahm2)(%)
25 99.1 8.2 865.9 63.4 2,375.0 10.2
BDD 75 100.0 10.8 3,385.3 247.7 798.6 3.4
125 100.0 13.8 7,200.0 526.92 479.2 2.1
25 39.1 4.2 1,132.8 82.9 937.5 4.0
Pt 75 52.2 8.3 4,978.8 364.4 416.7 1.8
125 60.9 12.3 10,515.4 769.5 291.7 1.3
25 27.0 3.8 1,488.8 108.95 645.8 2.8
Ti/Pt–IrO2 75 40.9 8.0 6,144.5 449.7 326.4 1.4
125 48.7 11.5 12,362.1 904.7 233.3 1.0
25 29.6 3.7 1,317.2 96.4 708.3 3.0
Ti/RuO2–TiO2 75 44.3 7.6 5,352.0 391.7 354.2 1.5
125 53.0 11.4 11,163.9 817.0 254.2 1.1
25 26.1 4.3 1,734.4 126.9 625.0 2.7
Ti/RuO2–IrO2 75 44.3 8.8 6,228.7 455.8 354.2 1.5
125 53.9 11.8 11,388.4 833.4 258.3 1.1
25 25.2 4.0 1,637.8 119.8 604.2 2.6
Ti/IrO2–Ta2O5 75 40.0 7.5 5,874.3 429.9 319.4 1.4
125 49.6 11.3 11,915.8 872.03 237.5 1.0

U: average voltage between electrodes, : anode efficiency, MCE: mineralization current efficiency, t for 360 min.

The SEC is one of the most critical factors dictating the economics of the electrooxidation process. The smaller the SEC, the more efficient the process. In the study, the SEC value increased when the current density was increased due to a reduction in the conversion rate of applied energy to •OH. The anode efficiency and mineralization current efficiency are the other important factors governing the economics of the electrooxidation process (Table 1). Although the removal efficiency of pollutants increases with increasing current density, a decrease in the current and anode efficiency is observed due to the mass transfer limitations and wasted energy (Comninellis et al. 2008). Both the anode efficiency and the mineralization current efficiency of the EO declined when the current density was increased for all anode materials. Overall, the BDD anode exhibited the highest mineralization efficiency even at the highest current density. Table 1 shows the strong role of anode type on the process efficiency as well as on the economy. As expected, for a current density of 25 mA/cm2 and 360 min process time, the anode efficiency of the BDD anode was 2,375 mg TOC/Ahm2, and the mineralization current efficiency was 10.2%. These values are 2.53 times higher than that of Pt electrodes and 3.7 times higher than other MMO electrodes. The electrical energy cost of the process was also calculated by taking into account the unit electrical energy price in Turkey (according to a February 2020 survey in the Turkish market, the price of electricity was 0.07318 US$/kWh). Moreover, the BDD anode exhibited a much lower energy consumption cost of US$65.40 to remove 1 kg TOC. In conclusion, the BDD electrode was selected as the most suitable electrode material due to the highest removal efficiency with the lowest energy consumption.

### The effect of operating parameters on BPA mineralization using BDD electrode

#### Effect of current density

The effect of the current density on the TOC removal efficiency was investigated at five different current densities (25, 50, 75, 100, and 125 mA/cm2) for a reaction time of 90 min. Figure 2(a) presents the effect of the current density on TOC removal efficiency. There was a direct relationship between the current density and TOC removal efficiency. As the current density applied to the electrooxidation cell was increased, the amount of TOC removed increased as well. At the end of the 90 min treatment time, TOC removal efficiency values for the current densities of 25, 50, 75, 100, and 125 mA/cm2 was 41%, 54%, 70%, 81% and 91%, respectively. The oxidative degradation of organics at the BDD anode has been reported to only take place in the potential region of water decomposition (Boye et al. 2006). As can be seen in Figure 2(a), the percentage of BPA mineralization was directly dependent on the applied current, with a higher value leading to increased TOC removal efficiencies.

Figure 2

(a) The effect of the current density on the TOC removal and (b) on SEC (experimental conditions: [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, stirring speed = 500 rpm, interelectrode distance = 15 mm, [H3PO4]: 0.25 M, conductivity 22.1 mS/cm, and anode = BDD).

Figure 2

(a) The effect of the current density on the TOC removal and (b) on SEC (experimental conditions: [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, stirring speed = 500 rpm, interelectrode distance = 15 mm, [H3PO4]: 0.25 M, conductivity 22.1 mS/cm, and anode = BDD).

Figure 2(b) shows the SEC values calculated based on the amount of TOC removed. The SEC values increased with the increasing current density applied. At the end of the 90 min treatment time, the SEC value for the current density of 25 mA/cm2 was 516 kWh/kg TOC and it was 1,864 kWh/kg TOC for the current density of 125 mA/cm2. At this stage, an increase in the current density led to an increase in TOC removal efficiency. However, SEC values are adversely affected by this. For instance, by increasing the current density five-fold, the TOC removal efficiency increased 2.25-fold; however, the SEC value increased by 3.6-fold. Therefore, it would be more economical to operate the process at a more extended refining period at a lower current density in order to achieve an acceptable SEC value.

#### Effect of stirring speed

The effect of stirring speed on TOC removal efficiency was investigated at five different stirring speeds (0, 250, 500, 750, and 1,000 rpm). Figure 3(a) demonstrates the effect of stirring speed on TOC removal efficiency from a BPA solution. There was no significant variation among the different stirring speeds in terms of TOC removal efficiency. Nevertheless, a slight improvement can be observed compared with the non-stirred condition. At the end of the 90 min treatment time, TOC removal efficiency values for the stirring speeds of 0, 250, 500, 750, and 1,000 rpm were 65%, 69%, 70%, 71%, and 71%, respectively.

Figure 3

(a) The effect of the stirring speed on the TOC removal and (b) on SEC (experimental conditions: [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, current density = 75 mA/cm2, interelectrode distance = 15 mm, [H3PO4] = 0.25 M, and anode = BDD).

Figure 3

(a) The effect of the stirring speed on the TOC removal and (b) on SEC (experimental conditions: [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, current density = 75 mA/cm2, interelectrode distance = 15 mm, [H3PO4] = 0.25 M, and anode = BDD).

Figure 3(b) shows SEC values calculated depending on the amount of TOC removed for five different stirring speed values. As the figure indicates, the SEC value decreases as the stirring speed increases. The SEC value for 0 rpm and TOC efficiency of 65% is 1,304 kWh/kg TOC, and is 1,024 kWh/kg TOC for 1,000 rpm and TOC efficiency of 71%. The difference in TOC removal efficiency between 1,000 rpm (the highest stirring speed) and 0 rpm is about 6%, and in parallel with this, the SEC value is about 27% less. This result shows that it is economically more advantageous to carry out the process at a high stirring speed. However, it should be kept in mind that there are also costs involved in carrying out the stirring process in the reactor.

#### Effect of interelectrode distance

The impact of the interelectrode distance on TOC removal efficiency was investigated at five different values (5, 10, 15, 20, and 25 mm). Figure 4 shows that the TOC removal efficiency for the distances of 5, 10, and 15 mm was almost the same, which was about 70%. When the distance was increased to 20 mm, TOC removal reached about 74%. However, an increase in the distance from 20 to 25 mm yielded no improvement in TOC removal efficiency.

Figure 4

(a) The effect of the interelectrode distance on the TOC removal efficiency and (b) on SEC (experimental conditions: [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, current density = 75 mA/cm2, stirring speed = 500 rpm, [H3PO4] = 0.25 M, conductivity = 22.1 mS/cm, and anode = BDD).

Figure 4

(a) The effect of the interelectrode distance on the TOC removal efficiency and (b) on SEC (experimental conditions: [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, current density = 75 mA/cm2, stirring speed = 500 rpm, [H3PO4] = 0.25 M, conductivity = 22.1 mS/cm, and anode = BDD).

Figure 4(b) shows that SEC values increased as the inter-electrode distance was increased. At the end of 90 min treatment time, although the TOC removal efficiency for the distances of 5, 10, and 15 mm was almost identical, a significant increase in the SEC values of respective distances was observed. The SEC value was 885 kWh/kg TOC for 5 mm distance and 1,137 kWh/kg TOC for 15 mm distance at the end of 90 treatment time.

The increase in the SEC values was due to the increase in resistance and potential difference, which are directly related to interelectrode distance. As the interelectrode distance increases, the electrical resistance passing through the solution increases and leading to an increase in the potential difference, which causes the SEC value to increase. The increase in SEC value can be up to twice as much. This is undesirable for the cost-effectiveness of the process.

#### Effect of BPA concentration

The effect of the concentration of BPA on TOC removal efficiency was investigated at five different initial concentrations (50, 100, 150, 200, and 250 mg/L) and the results are presented in Figure 5. As can be seen from the figure, there was a significant decline in the TOC removal efficiency as the initial BPA concentration was increased. At the end of 90-min treatment time, TOC removal efficiency values for initial BPA concentrations of 50, 100, 150, 200, and 250 mg/L were 100%, 74%, 70%, 62% and 57%, respectively. Complete mineralization was obtained at the initial concentration of 50 mg/L with a 100% TOC removal rate. However, in relation to the amount (mg/L) of TOC removed, the mineralization performance was greater at higher initial concentrations. This was mainly due to the utilization of •OH in the presence of more pollutant molecules, thus avoiding the O2 evolution reaction (Brillas et al. 2004).

Figure 5

(a) The effect of BPA concentration on the TOC removal efficiency and (b) on SEC (experimental conditions: interelectrode distance = 15 mm, current density = 75 mA/cm2, stirring speed = 500 rpm, [H3PO4] = 0.25 M, conductivity = 22.1 mS/cm, and anode = BDD).

Figure 5

(a) The effect of BPA concentration on the TOC removal efficiency and (b) on SEC (experimental conditions: interelectrode distance = 15 mm, current density = 75 mA/cm2, stirring speed = 500 rpm, [H3PO4] = 0.25 M, conductivity = 22.1 mS/cm, and anode = BDD).

As Figure 5(b) shows, the SEC values decreased with increasing BPA concentrations. This occurrence was due to the difference in the amount of the substance removed for the same amount of electricity. Reduction in the mineralization efficiency with increasing BPA concentrations was an expected outcome because the process under the same conditions had to deal with more pollutants. Although BPA was entirely mineralized at an initial concentration of 50 mg/L, only 57% of BPA was mineralized at a concentration of 250 mg/L. However, this efficiency value (57%) corresponds to 143 mg/L BPA, which is almost three times the concentration of 50 mg/L. When considered together with the SEC parameter, operating the process at high concentrations is desirable for SEC value. However, it is thought that extremely high concentrations will inhibit the process by causing electro-polymerization in the anode electrode.

#### Effect of electrolyte concentration

Electrochemical processes are strongly affected by the type and the concentration of the supporting electrolytes used (Keyikoglu et al. 2019). The effect of the electrolyte concentration on the TOC removal efficiency was investigated at five different H3PO4 concentrations (0.0625, 0.125, 0.25, 0.50, and 0.75 M). As displayed in Figure 6(a), TOC removal efficiency was almost the same around 69–70% for the concentrations of 0.0625, 0.125, and 0.25 M. For the electrolyte concentrations of 0.375 and 0.5 M, there was an increase in the TOC removal efficiency, which reached 74% and 79%, respectively.

Figure 6

(a) The effect of the electrolyte (phosphoric acid) concentration on the TOC removal efficiency, (b) on the SEC experimental conditions = [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, current density = 75 mA/cm2, stirring speed = 500 rpm, interelectrode distance = 15 mm, and anode = BDD).

Figure 6

(a) The effect of the electrolyte (phosphoric acid) concentration on the TOC removal efficiency, (b) on the SEC experimental conditions = [BPA]0 = 150 mg/L, current density = 75 mA/cm2, stirring speed = 500 rpm, interelectrode distance = 15 mm, and anode = BDD).

Figure 6(b) shows that the SEC value decreased as the electrolyte concentration was increased. Although the TOC removal efficiencies with electrolyte concentrations of 0.0625, 0.125, and 0.25 M were almost the same, the SEC values decreased at the same electrolyte concentrations. This was due to the decreased resistance and potential difference that resulted from the increase in the interelectrode conductivity. At the end of 90 min treatment time, the SEC value for the electrolyte concentration of 0.0625 M and TOC removal efficiency of 69% was 1,859 kWh/kg TOC and 928 kWh/kg TOC for the concentration of 0.5 M electrolyte and TOC removal efficiency of 79%. An eight-fold increase in the amount of electrolyte led to an increase of about 10% in the removal efficiency and a decrease in the SEC value of about 50%. A high electrolyte concentration had a positive effect on the SEC value by reducing the electrical resistance by decreasing the potential difference.

This study investigated the performance of different anode materials on the mineralization of BPA by an EO process. The results indicated that, unlike the chemical bonding of •OH by MMO electrodes, BDD electrodes physically bind •OH and thus provide high oxidation capacity. The possible degradation pathway of BPA by electrocatalytic oxidation was reported to occur via the attack of •OH to the aromatic ring in the BPA molecule (Wu et al. 2016). The formation of BPA 3,4-quinone was shown to cause DNA damage in the liver (Sakuma et al. 2010), and any treatment technology must therefore warrant complete mineralization of BPA to avoid the formation of toxic by-products. In the present study, the BDD electrode was the only one to achieve complete mineralization of BPA, which ensures the safe discharge of BPA-containing wastewaters. Even though BDD costs 18 times more than Pt/O2 and 36 times more than MMO electrodes, the high mineralization of BDD compensated for the material cost and showed considerably lower SEC values while yielding a higher current efficiency than other anode materials tested. However, the major disadvantage of these electrodes is the material cost, which must be taken into account in the cost assessment of the overall process.

## CONCLUSIONS

In this study, we examined the mineralization of BPA by the EO process using different anode materials. The comparison was made between BDD, Pt, and several MMO electrodes in terms of mineralization efficiency of BPA. BDD electrode was the only anode that achieved 100% mineralization of BPA in 180 min and at the current density of 125 mA/cm2. Pt appeared to be relatively better than the MMO electrodes, achieving 60.9% TOC removal efficiencies compared with the MMO electrodes, whose TOC removal efficiency ranged between 48% and 54%. BDD electrode was also more advantageous than the other electrodes for energy efficiency, with an SEC value of 865.9 kWh/kg TOC, which corresponds to a treatment cost of 63.4 US$/kg TOC. In comparison, the treatment cost was calculated for Pt, Ti/Pt–IrO2, Ti/RuO2–TiO2, Ti/RuO2–IrO2, Ti/IrO2–Ta2O5 as 82.9 US$/kg, 108.95 US$/kg, 96.4 US$/kg, 126.9 US$/kg, and 119.8 US$/kg, respectively. Similarly, the current efficiency of BDD anodes was 2.53 times higher than that of Pt electrodes and 3.7 times higher than other MMO electrodes. Both the process performance and the energy consumption of the electrooxidation process were influenced by the operating conditions. The effect of current density, initial BPA concentration, and the electrolyte concentration was more significant than the stirring speed and interelectrode distance. In this regard, more attention should be given to the parameters that have the most effect on process performance.

## DECLARATION OF COMPETING INTEREST

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

## DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT

All relevant data are included in the paper or its Supplementary Information.

## REFERENCES

T.
M.
Ruksana
Alhabarah
A. N.
Alshehri
S. M.
2019
N/S doped highly porous magnetic carbon aerogel derived from sugarcane bagasse cellulose for the removal of bisphenol-A
.
International Journal of Biological Macromolecules
132
,
1031
1038
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijbiomac.2019.04.004
.
Alshehri
S. M.
M.
T.
Alothman
Z. A.
Aldalbahi
A.
2014
Synthesis, characterization of curcumin based ecofriendly antimicrobial bio-adsorbent for the removal of phenol from aqueous medium
.
Chemical Engineering Journal
254
,
181
189
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cej.2014.05.100
.
Bourgin
M.
Bichon
E.
Antignac
J. P.
Monteau
F.
Leroy
G.
Barritaud
L.
Chachignon
M.
Ingrand
V.
Roche
P.
Le Bizec
B.
2013
Chlorination of bisphenol A: non-targeted screening for the identification of transformation products and assessment of estrogenicity in generated water
.
Chemosphere
93
(
11
),
2814
2822
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2013.09.080
.
Boye
B.
Brillas
E.
Marselli
B.
Michaud
P.-A.
Comninellis
C.
Farnia
G.
Sandonà
G.
2006
Electrochemical incineration of chloromethylphenoxy herbicides in acid medium by anodic oxidation with boron-doped diamond electrode
.
Electrochimica Acta
51
(
14
),
2872
2880
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.electacta.2005.08.019
.
Brillas
E.
Boye
B.
Sirés
I.
Garrido
J. A.
Rodrı́guez
R. M.
Arias
C.
Cabot
P.-L.
Comninellis
C.
2004
Electrochemical destruction of chlorophenoxy herbicides by anodic oxidation and electro-Fenton using a boron-doped diamond electrode
.
Electrochimica Acta
49
(
25
),
4487
4496
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.electacta.2004.05.006
.
Can
O. T.
2015
Removal of TOC from fertilizer production wastewater by electrooxidation
.
Desalination and Water Treatment
53
(
4
),
919
927
.
https://doi.org/10.1080/19443994.2013.845736
.
Can
O. T.
Bayramoglu
M.
Sozbir
M.
Aras
O.
2019a
Mineralization of o-tolidine by electrooxidation with BDD, Ti/Pt and MMO anodes
.
Desalination and Water Treatment
141
,
377
385
.
https://doi.org/10.5004/dwt.2019.23311
.
Can
O. T.
Gengec
E.
Kobya
M.
2019b
TOC and COD removal from instant coffee and coffee products production wastewater by chemical coagulation assisted electrooxidation
.
Journal of Water Process Engineering
28
(
September 2018
),
28
35
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jwpe.2019.01.002
.
Comninellis
C.
1994
Electrocatalysis in the electrochemical conversion/combustion of organic pollutants for waste water treatment
.
Electrochimica Acta
39
(
11–12
),
1857
1862
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/0013-4686(94)85175-1
.
Comninellis
Ch.
Pulgarin
C.
1991
Anodic oxidation of phenol for waste water treatment
.
Journal of Applied Electrochemistry
21
(
8
),
703
708
.
https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01034049
.
Comninellis
C.
Kapalka
A.
Malato
S.
Parsons
S. A.
Poulios
I.
Mantzavinos
D.
2008
.
Journal of Chemical Technology & Biotechnology
83
(
May
),
769
776
.
https://doi.org/10.1002/jctb.1873
.
Cui
Y.
Li
X.
Chen
G.
2009
Electrochemical degradation of bisphenol A on different anodes
.
Water Research
43
(
7
),
1968
1976
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2009.01.026
.
Dhiman
P.
M.
Batoo
K. M.
Kumar
A.
Sharma
G.
Ghfar
A. A.
Kumar
G.
Singh
M.
2017
Nano FexZn1−xO as a tuneable and efficient photocatalyst for solar powered degradation of bisphenol A from aqueous environment
.
Journal of Cleaner Production
165
,
1542
1556
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.07.245
.
Dietrich
M.
Franke
M.
Stelter
M.
Braeutigam
P.
2017
Degradation of endocrine disruptor bisphenol A by ultrasound-assisted electrochemical oxidation in water
.
Ultrasonics Sonochemistry
39
(
November 2016
),
741
749
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ultsonch.2017.05.038
.
Ding
X.
Ai
Z.
Zhang
L.
2012
Design of a visible light driven photo-electrochemical/electro-Fenton coupling oxidation system for wastewater treatment
.
Journal of Hazardous Materials
239–240
,
233
240
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2012.08.070
.
Dong
J.
Zhao
W.
Zhou
S.
Zhang
C.
Fu
D.
2019
Transformation of bisphenol A by electrochemical oxidation in the presence of nitrite and formation of nitrated aromatic by-products
.
Chemosphere
236
,
124835
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2019.124835
.
Enache
T. A.
Chiorcea-Paquim
A. M.
Fatibello-Filho
O.
Oliveira-Brett
A. M.
2009
Hydroxyl radicals electrochemically generated in situ on a boron-doped diamond electrode
.
Electrochemistry Communications
11
(
7
),
1342
1345
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.elecom.2009.04.017
.
A.
Mardani
G.
2014
Sonophotolytıc technology for removal of bısphenol A in aqueous solutıon
.
Fresenius Environmental Bulletin
23
,
1720
1726
.
Fiege
H.
Voges
H.-W.
Hamamoto
T.
Umemura
S.
Iwata
T.
Miki
H.
Fujita
Y.
H.-J.
Garbe
D.
Paulus
W.
2000
Phenol Derivatives. In Ullmann's Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry, Wiley–VCH. https://doi.org/10.1002/14356007.a19_313
.
Flint
S.
Markle
T.
Thompson
S.
Wallace
E.
2012
Bisphenol A exposure, effects, and policy: a wildlife perspective
.
Journal of Environmental Management
104
,
19
34
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2012.03.021
.
Gengec
E.
Kobya
M.
2013
Treatment of baker's yeast wastewater by electrocoagulation and evaluation of molecular weight distribution with HPSEC
.
Separation Science and Technology
48
(
18
),
2880
2889
.
https://doi.org/10.1080/01496395.2013.804087
.
Govindaraj
M.
Rathinam
R.
Sukumar
C.
Uthayasankar
M.
Pattabhi
S.
2013
Electrochemical oxidation of bisphenol-A from aqueous solution using graphite electrodes
.
Environmental Technology (United Kingdom)
34
(
4
),
503
511
.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09593330.2012.701333
.
Groenen Serrano
K.
2018
Indirect electrochemical oxidation using hydroxyl radical, active chlorine, and peroxodisulfate
.
Electrochemical Water and Wastewater Treatment
133
164
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-813160-2.00006-7
.
Kang
J.-H.
Aasi
D.
Katayama
Y.
2007
Bisphenol A in the aquatic environment and its endocrine-disruptive effects on aquatic organisms
.
Critical Reviews in Toxicology
37
(
7
),
607
625
.
https://doi.org/10.1080/10408440701493103
.
Keyikoglu
R.
Can
O. T.
Aygun
A.
Tek
A.
2019
Comparison of the effects of various supporting electrolytes on the treatment of a dye solution by electrocoagulation process
.
Colloids and Interface Science Communications
33
(
July
),
100210
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.colcom.2019.100210
.
Kumar
A.
Kumar
A.
Sharma
G.
Al-Muhtaseb
A. H.
M.
Ghfar
A. A.
Guo
C.
F. J.
2018
Biochar-templated g-C3N4/Bi2O2CO3/CoFe2O4 nano-assembly for visible and solar assisted photo-degradation of paraquat, nitrophenol reduction and CO2 conversion
.
Chemical Engineering Journal
339
(
November 2017
),
393
410
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cej.2018.01.105
.
Kuramitz
H.
Nakata
Y.
Kawasaki
M.
Tanaka
S.
2001
Electrochemical oxidation of bisphenol A. Application to the removal of bisphenol A using a carbon fiber electrode
.
Chemosphere
45
(
1
),
37
43
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0045-6535(01)00032-7
.
Lee
C.-H.
Lee
E.-S.
Lim
Y.-K.
Park
K.-H.
Park
H.-D.
Lim
D.-S.
2017
Enhanced electrochemical oxidation of phenol by boron-doped diamond nanowire electrode
.
7
(
11
),
6229
6235
.
https://doi.org/10.1039/C6RA26287B
.
Li
H.
Long
Y.
Zhu
X.
Tian
Y.
Ye
J.
2017
Influencing factors and chlorinated byproducts in electrochemical oxidation of bisphenol A with boron-doped diamond anodes
.
Electrochimica Acta
246
,
1121
1130
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.electacta.2017.06.163
.
Martínez-Huitle
C. A.
L. S.
2011
Electrocatalysis in wastewater treatment: recent mechanism advances
.
Quimica Nova
34
,
850
858
.
Martínez-Huitle
C. A.
Ferro
S.
2006
Electrochemical oxidation of organic pollutants for the wastewater treatment: direct and indirect processes
.
Chemical Society Reviews
35
(
12
),
1324
1340
.
https://doi.org/10.1039/b517632 h
.
Martínez-Huitle
C. A.
Rodrigo
M. A.
Sirés
I.
Scialdone
O.
2015
Single and coupled electrochemical processes and reactors for the abatement of organic water pollutants: a critical review
.
Chemical Reviews
115
(
24
),
13362
13407
.
https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.chemrev.5b00361
.
Maruyama
H.
Seki
H.
Matsukawa
Y.
Suzuki
A.
Inoue
N.
2006
Removal of bisphenol A and diethyl phthalate from aqueous phases by ultrasonic atomization
.
Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research
45
(
18
),
6383
6386
.
https://doi.org/10.1021/ie060353s
.
Mezohegyi
G.
Erjavec
B.
Kaplan
R.
Pintar
A.
2013
Removal of bisphenol A and its oxidation products from aqueous solutions by sequential catalytic wet air oxidation and biodegradation
.
Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research
52
(
26
),
9301
9307
.
https://doi.org/10.1021/ie400998t
.
M.
Vasseghian
Y.
Khataee
A.
Kobya
M.
H.
Dragoi
E.-N.
2020
Service life and stability of electrodes applied in electrochemical advanced oxidation processes: a comprehensive review
.
Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry
87
,
18
39
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jiec.2020.03.038
.
Murugananthan
M.
Yoshihara
S.
Rakuma
T.
Shirakashi
T.
2008
Mineralization of bisphenol A (BPA) by anodic oxidation with boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrode
.
Journal of Hazardous Materials
154
(
1
),
213
220
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhazmat.2007.10.011
.
Neamţu
M.
Frimmel
F. H.
2006
Degradation of endocrine disrupting bisphenol A by 254 nm irradiation in different water matrices and effect on yeast cells
.
Water Research
40
(
20
),
3745
3750
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2006.08.019
.
Oke
O.
Ogundugba
S.
2014
Removal and Mineralization of Bisphenol A by Ozonation Process
.
International Conference on Chemical, Agricultural and Medical Sciences, Antalya
.
Panizza
M.
Cerisola
G.
2009
Direct and mediated anodic oxidation of organic pollutants
.
Chemical Reviews
109
(
12
),
6541
6569
.
https://doi.org/10.1021/cr9001319
.
Prokop
Z.
Hanková
L.
Jeřábek
K.
2004
Bisphenol A synthesis – modeling of industrial reactor and catalyst deactivation
.
Reactive and Functional Polymers
60
,
77
83
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.reactfunctpolym.2004.02.013
.
Sakuma
S.
Nakanishi
M.
Morinaga
K.
Fujitake
M.
S. I.
Fujimoto
Y.
2010
Bisphenol A 3,4-quinone induces the conversion of xanthine dehydrogenase into oxidase in vitro
.
Food and Chemical Toxicology
48
,
2217
2222
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fct.2010.05.051
.
Soni
B. D.
Patel
U. D.
Agrawal
A.
Ruparelia
J. P.
2017
Application of BDD and DSA electrodes for the removal of RB 5 in batch and continuous operation
.
Journal of Water Process Engineering
17
,
11
21
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jwpe.2017.01.009
.
Tsai
W.-T.
2006
Human health risk on environmental exposure to bisphenol-A: a review
.
Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part C
24
(
2
),
225
255
.
https://doi.org/10.1080/10590500600936482
.
Turan
A.
Keyikoglu
R.
Kobya
M.
Khataee
A.
2020
Degradation of thiocyanate by electrochemical oxidation process from coke oven wastewater: role of operative parameters and mechanistic study
.
Chemosphere
127014
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.127014
.
Wu
W.
Huang
Z. H.
Lim
T. T.
2016
A comparative study on electrochemical oxidation of bisphenol A by boron-doped diamond anode and modified SnO2-Sb anodes: influencing parameters and reaction pathways
.
Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering
4
(
3
),
2807
2815
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jece.2016.05.034
.
Xue
B.
Zhang
Y.
Wang
J. Y.
2011
Electrochemical oxidation of bisphenol A on Ti/SnO2–Sb2O5/PbO2 anode for waste water treatment
.
Procedia Environmental Sciences
10
(
PART A
),
647
652
.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proenv.2011.09.104
.
Zaouak
A.
Matoussi
F.
Dachraoui
M.
2013
Electrochemical oxidation of herbicide bifenox acid in aqueous medium using diamond thin film electrode
.
Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part B
48
(
10
),
878
884
.
Zaouak
A.
Matoussi
F.
Dachraoui
M.
2014
Electrochemical degradation of a chlorophenoxy propionic acid derivative used as an herbicide at boron-doped diamond
.
Desalination and Water Treatment
52
(
7–9
),
1662
1668
.
Zhi
J. F.
Wang
H. B.
Nakashima
T.
Rao
T. N.
Fujishima
A.
2003
Electrochemical incineration of organic pollutants on boron-doped diamond electrode. Evidence for direct electrochemical oxidation pathway
.
Journal of Physical Chemistry B
107
(
48
),
13389
13395
.
https://doi.org/10.1021/jp030279 g
.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Licence (CC BY 4.0), which permits copying, adaptation and redistribution, provided the original work is properly cited (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).